2021
The Cowen-Douglas Theory for Operator Tuples and Similarity
Abstract
We are concerned with the similarity problem for Cowen-Douglas operator tuples. The unitary equivalence counterpart was already investigated in the 1970’s and geometric concepts including vector bundles and curvature appeared in the description. As the Cowen-Douglas conjecture show, the study of the similarity problem has not been so successful until quite recently. The latest results reveal the close correlation between complex geometry, the corona problem, and the similarity problem for single Cowen-Douglas operators. Without making use of the corona theorems that no longer hold in the multi-variable setting, we prove that the single operator results for similarity remain true for Cowen-Douglas operator tuples as well.
keywords:
The Cowen-Douglas class, Similarity, Complex bundles, Curvature inequalitypacs:
[MSC]Primary 47B13, 32L05; Secondary 32A10, 32A36, 32Q05
1 Introduction
To study equivalence problems for bounded linear operators on Hilbert space to which standard methods do not apply, M. J. Cowen and R. G. Douglas introduced in the late 1970’s, a class of operators with a holomorphic eigenvector bundle structure CD ; CD2 . Prior to the introduction of the Cowen-Douglas class, the discussion on operator equivalence for even the adjoints of various shift operators (the most-mentioned entities in the study of operators) was non-existent. Their influential work connects concepts and results from complex geometry to the fundamental problem of determining operator equivalence. Note that when one considers operators that are defined on finite-dimensional Hilbert space, the well-known Jordan Canonical Form Theorem and the results by C. Pearcy Pearcy and W. Specht Specht give a complete answer to this problem.
For a complex separable Hilbert space , let denote the algebra of bounded linear operators on . For , let and be -tuples of commuting operators on . If there is a unitary operator such that , then and are said to be unitarily equivalent (denoted by ). If there is an invertible operator such that , then and are similar (denoted by ).
Given , first define an operator by
for . Let be a bounded domain of the -dimensional complex plane and consider . If one sets , then it is easily seen that
Definition 1.1.
For and , the Cowen-Douglas class consists of -tuples of commuting operators satisfying the following conditions:
-
(1)
is closed for all ;
-
(2)
for all ; and
-
(3)
is dense in .
For an -tuple of commuting operators M. J. Cowen and R. G. Douglas proved in CD ; CD2 that an associated holomorphic eigenvector bundle over of rank exists, where
Furthermore, it was shown that two operator tuples and in are unitarily equivalent if and only if the vector bundles and are equivalent as Hermitian holomorphic vector bundles. They also showed that every -tuple can be realized as the adjoint of an -tuple of multiplication operators by the coordinate functions on a Hilbert space of holomorphic functions on .
For if we let be a holomorphic frame of and form the Gram matrix for then the curvature and the corresponding curvature matrix with entries , of the bundle are given by the formulas
(1.1) |
Note that we omit the notation in without any ambiguity. Since the above formulas depend on the selection of the holomorphic frame, they are also written as and , respectively, should the need arise. In the special case of , the curvature of the line bundle can be defined alternately as
where is a non-vanishing holomorphic section of . In BKM , S. Biswas, D. K. Keshari, and G. Misra showed that the curvature matrix of any is negative-definite. Moreover, in CD , it was shown that for , if and only if The curvature , along with certain covariant derivations of the curvature, form a complete set of unitary invariants for an operator and this is another main result of CD . In CS , R. E. Curto and N. Salinas established a relationship between the class and generalized reproducing kernels to describe when two -tuples are unitarily equivalent. A similarity result for Cowen-Douglas operators in geometric terms such as curvature had been much more difficult to obtain. In fact, the work of D. N. Clark and G. Misra in CM2 ; CM showed that the Cowen-Douglas conjecture that similarity can be determined from the behavior of the quotient of the entries of curvature matrices was false.
The corona problem of complex analysis is closely related to operator theory and complex geometry Carleson1962 ; N ; NKN ; NF1970 ; U . In particular, M. Uchiyama characterized the contractive operators that are similar to the adjoint of some multiplication operator in the work U based on the corona theorem due to M. Rosenblum in R . The following lemma given by N. K. Nikolski shows how to use the notion of projections , , to solve the corona problem. The space denotes the algebra of bounded analytic functions defined on a domain whose function values are bounded linear operators from a Hilbert space to another one :
Lemma 1.2 (Nikolski’s Lemma).
Let satisfy for some and for all . Then is left invertible in (i.e., there exists a such that ) if and only if there exists a function whose values are projections (not necessarily orthogonal) onto for all . Moreover, if such an analytic projection exists, then one can find a left inverse satisfying .
For , where denotes the unit disk, let denote the orthogonal projection onto , for each . In KT , the third author and S. Treil described when a contraction is similar to copies of , the adjoint of the shift operator on the Hardy space of the unit disk , in terms of the curvature matrices. It was proven that if and only if
for some bounded subharmonic function defined on and for all . For , (see HJK ; JS ), while for the Hardy shift . The result was then generalized to other shift operators in DKT . Note that this is consistent with the curvature inequality result of G. Misra given in M .
The similarity results mentioned above rely, to some extent, on a model theorem and a well-known -method that has been used extensively in recent years to solve numerous versions of the corona problem Lars1967 . For a contraction , the model theory of B. Sz.-Nagy and C. Foiaş provides the canonical model as a complete set of invariants. Model theorems for operator tuples in were also studied under various assumptions NF1970 ; NF . Since one cannot relate the similarity problem to the corona problem easily anymore in the multi-operator setting, we propose an alternative approach in managing the similarity of tuples of operators in for .
Inspired by the previous similarity results, we first give a sufficient condition for the similarity between and the adjoint of the operator tuple on a weighted Bergman space defined on the unit ball of . The characterization is given in terms of the defect operator corresponding to . Note that there already exist a number of necessary conditions for similarity – it is a sufficient condition that had been hard to obtain. Throughout the paper, defined on a Hilbert space of holomorphic functions on will denote the tuple of multiplication operators by the coordinate functions
for and . It can be checked that where .
Theorem 1.3.
Let and consider the operator tuple on a weighted Bergman space , where . Suppose that and , where , for an orthonormal basis for . If there exist a non-vanishing holomorphic section of and a unit vector such that
then .
Although there is no general corona theorem that works for higher-order domains, a related condition that will be called condition in Section 3 will play a significant role in the formulation of another sufficient condition for similarity in terms of curvature matrices. The space denotes the collection of bounded analytic functions defined on the domain .
Theorem 1.4.
Let and consider the operator tuple on a Hilbert space defined on with reproducing kernel Suppose that and that there exist an isometry and a Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle over such that
If the bundle satisfies condition via , then .
A number of corollaries are given in Section 4. The result of DKT and KT describing contractive Cowen-Douglas operators that are similar to using curvature is generalized in the commuting operator tuples setting. Moreover, this description is also used to obtain a sufficient condition for the similarity between arbitrary Cowen-Douglas operator tuples in . The space denotes the commutant of the operator tuple .
Theorem 1.5.
Let be such that . Suppose that
for some , where are holomorphic functions defined on . If there exists an integer satisfying for all , then , and . In particular, when , and are unitarily equivalent.
2 Preliminaries
2.1 Reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces
Let be the open unit ball of . The space of all holomorphic functions defined on will be denoted as while will stand for the space of all bounded holomorphic functions on . For a function , the radial derivative of is defined to be . Once it is set that , we have for every , . In particular, for a homogeneous polynomial of degree , We will also need the familiar multi-index notation . As is well-known, and . For , and whenever for every
The work ARS ; hartz ; ZhaoZhu2008 offer good references for what follows. For a real number , one can consider the family of holomorphic function spaces
Recall that a reproducing kernel Hilbert space is a Hilbert space of functions on a set with the property that the evaluation at each is a bounded linear functional on By the Riesz representation theorem, for each , there exists a function such that for all
The function defined by is called the reproducing kernel of When , is a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with reproducing kernel
If is such that , then the space can also be represented as
(2.1) |
where denotes the normalized volume measure on . The spaces are closely related to the analytic Besov-Sobolev spaces . Recall that for , and , the space contains with where denotes the Lebesgue measure on and is the invariant measure on . Well-known examples in this family of spaces include the Dirichlet space , the Drury-Arveson space , the Hardy space , and the Bergman space . Moreover, with give weighted Dirichlet-type spaces while those with represent weighted Bergman spaces.
2.2 Operator-valued multipliers
As every Hilbert space of functions on a set comes with a corresponding multiplier algebra
it is natural to consider the multipliers of reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces. For every multiplier , there is an associated multiplication operator defined by with . In particular, for weighted Bergman spaces with , . For , the multiplier norm on the Drury-Arveson space is no longer equal to the supremum norm on the unit ball and therefore,
Let be a Hilbert space. The Hilbert space tensor product can be regarded as the space of all holomorphic functions with Taylor series , where and
Now, for Hilbert spaces and , let be an operator-valued function. Given , we define a function as
Denote by the space of all for which for every . An element is said to be a multiplier and is called an operator of multiplication by . The space is endowed with the norm We now list some basic properties of multipliers.
Lemma 2.1.
For a weighted Bergman space with and a Hilbert space ,
Proof: Taking in (2.1), we have for every and ,
This means that and therefore, Conversely, since , The following results are well-known. The first lemma can be found in AM2002 :
Lemma 2.2.
Let be an operator-valued function. If , then
Conversely, if and the mapping extends to a bounded operator , then and
Lemma 2.3.
Let be the adjoint of the multiplication tuple on , . If , then
The following lemma, due to J. A. Ball, T. T. Trent, and V. Vinnikov, characterizes for the Drury-Arveson space . For the proof and additional results, see BTV2001 ; EP2002 :
Lemma 2.4.
Let . Then the following statements are equivalent:
-
(1)
with
-
(2)
The kernel
is a positive, sesqui-analytic, -valued kernel on , i.e., there is an auxiliary Hilbert space and a holomorphic -valued function on such that for all
2.3 Model theorem
Let be the multiplication tuple on a reproducing kernel Hilbert space defined on such that for every
For an -tuple of commuting operators and a multi-index , let and . Suppose that is a polynomial and that , where given a polynomial , we let . The defect operator of is then defined to be
We next define a mapping as
for , where and is an orthonormal basis for . Then according to the result of C. G. Ambrozie, M. Engli, and V. Mller in AEM , is a unitary operator satisfying for . The study of a model theorem for bounded linear operators have been quite extensive and can be found in Agler1982 ; A2 ; AEM ; Athavale1978 ; Athavale1992 ; CV1993 ; CV1995 ; MV1993 ; Pott1999 . The following model theorem for a tuple of commuting operators is stated in AEM :
Theorem 2.5.
Consider the operator tuple on a Hilbert space of holomorphic functions with reproducing kernel such that is a polynomial. For an orthonormal basis for , let . Then the following statements are equivalent:
-
(1)
is unitarily equivalent to the restriction of to an invariant subspace.
-
(2)
and for .
3 Similarity in the class
We first give a sufficient condition for the similarity between operator tuples and on a weighted Bergman space by using the defect operator and the model theorem given previously. We then introduce condition for Hermitian holomorphic vector bundles (see Subsection 3.2) and use it together with the curvature and its covariant derivatives to characterize similarity in the class . The similarity of operators inside a specific subclass of and the uniqueness of decomposition of Cowen-Douglas operators are then discussed.
3.1 Model theorem and similarity
We start by investigating the eigenvector bundle of .
Lemma 3.1.
Let and consider the operator tuple on a Hilbert space of holomorphic functions with reproducing kernel such that is a polynomial. Suppose that satisfies either one of the equivalent statements in Theorem 2.5. Then for any
Proof: Let be an orthonormal basis for . Since , for every . Defining a mapping as
for and , we have
From AEM , is unitary and the result follows. The next theorem is the first of our main results of the paper.
Theorem 3.2.
Let and consider the operator tuple on a weighted Bergman space , where Suppose that and , where , for an orthonormal basis for . If there exist a non-vanishing holomorphic section of and a unit vector such that
(3.1) |
then .
Proof: Let and note by Theorem 2.5 that , where is an invariant subspace of . By Lemma 3.1, we then have
Given a unit vector , one can select an orthonormal basis of to express as If we set
then .
Now define an operator-valued function by
Since we know that for a weighted Bergman space with
Lemma 2.2 and condition (3.1) yield
Hence, is bounded and for ,
Since , the definition of curvature from (1.1) then gives
Finally, let
Obviously, and so that for any
This shows that and since , as claimed.
Remark 3.3.
After an obvious modification of the condition and the form of tailored to the reproducing kernel , Theorem 3.2 can be generalized to any operator tuple on a reproducing kernel Hilbert space such that is a polynomial as long as . Moreover, one can use Lemma 2.4 to check the multiplier algebra condition when working on the similarity between a row-contraction and the operator tuple on the Drury-Arveson space .
3.2 Complex bundles and similarity
Denote by an orthonormal basis for and let a Hilbert space on and analytic vector valued functions over be given, where . Let be an -dimensional Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle over , be holomorphic cross-sections of which form a frame for on . For , set and . We will say that condition holds for the Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle via if there exist functions and such that , , , , and for all Using the curvature and covariant derivatives of complex bundles as well as condition , we give a similarity description in the class .
Lemma 3.4.
Let and be Hermitian holomorphic bundles over of rank and of , respectively. Then for any ,
Proof: Let and be holomorphic frames of and of , respectively. Then is a holomorphic frame of and so that
It follows that for with in the -th position,
and
Next, if
holds for some , then
and
for any Hence,
for all . Since without loss of generality, we have for
it is easy to see that
We are now ready to prove our second main theorem of the paper.
Theorem 3.5.
Let and consider the operator tuple on a Hilbert space defined on with reproducing kernel Suppose that and that there exist an isometry and a Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle over such that
(3.2) |
If the bundle satisfies condition via , then .
Proof: First, from and the definition of condition , we know that is -dimensional Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle. Without losing generality, assume that is a frame of . It is easy to see that the Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle is expressed as
where is an orthonormal basis for . By Lemma 3.4 and , we then have for some isometry and for all ,
It is also proven in CD3 that is congruent to , that is, there is a unitary operator such that
(3.3) |
Next, since the Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle satisfies condition , for the holomorphic frame of , there exist and such that for every , where A proof similar to the one used in Lemma 2.2 then implies that for ,
where is an orthonormal basis for . In addition, for and ,
where is an orthonormal basis for . Hence,
This shows that
Furthermore, since , we have and Combining these results and taking into account the operator , we obtain
for and Therefore, so that is an invertible operator satisfying
From this and , we conclude that the invertible operator establishes the similarity between and .
The following corollary should be compared to M. Uchiyama’s result in U . It is already known that the result holds for weighted Bergman spaces , :
Corollary 3.6.
Let and consider the operator tuple on a Hilbert space such that . If for some Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle over , where and is bounded by positive constants, then
Remark 3.7.
Condition is related to the corona theorem. Let and consider the operator tuple on a Hilbert space defined on . Suppose that for some Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle over , where is such that and . Let there exist a constant satisfying
(3.4) |
and a function such that
for and . Then condition (3.4) implies the existence of such that
Setting , one can proceed as in the proof of Theorem 3.5 to conclude that .
Corollary 3.8.
Let and . If
for some Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle of rank , then if and only if satisfies condition via .
Proof: Suppose first that there exists a bounded invertible operator such that Then satisfies
for a holomorphic frame of and orthonormal bases and for and for , respectively. Note that since is a bounded linear operator, the are uniformly bounded on Thus, we can define a function as
where Obviously, the function defined on as is such that Moreover, since
Next, note from Theorem 3.5 that
and that the operator has dense range. Since is invertible, this means that . Furthermore, for every , and there exists a such that
It follows that since and , there exists a function such that , that is, , for every .
Conversely, if the complex bundle satisfies condition , then there is a holomorphic frame of and functions and such that
for all , , and an orthonormal basis of . Another application of Theorem 3.5 yields a bounded invertible operator . Now, since , there is a unitary operator such that for Then, is a bounded invertible operator establishing the similarity between and .
The Dirichlet space consists of all analytic functions defined on the unit disk satisfying It is well-known that the reproducing kernel of is given as , for . Research on similarity on the Dirichlet space can be found in HKK2016 , for instance. Using the results of Luo2022 , we now give a sufficient condition for a Cowen-Douglas operator to be similar to on .
Corollary 3.9.
Let and consider the operator on the Dirichlet space . Suppose that for some Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle over , where and for . If
where
and is the normalized area measure, then
In order to investigate similarity between tuples of irreducible operators in the Cowen-Douglas class , we introduce a subclass denoted . The subclass is the collection of all of the form
where and the , , are non-zero operators such that for all . The class was defined in JJDG , and in JKSX ; JJD , the corresponding similarity question was considered. We now give a sufficient condition for the similarity between and , where
is in and is in for .
Theorem 3.10.
Let , where for some and for all . Suppose that the following conditions hold:
-
(1)
where for some analytic vector valued function over .
-
(2)
Condition holds for the Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle , with , via , .
-
(3)
There exist functions such that for all and ,
where , , and for
-
(4)
and for all and .
Then
Proof: We can assume from condition (1) that , where for analytic vector valued function over . Furthermore, for some . Note also that if we let in condition (3), then
(3.5) |
Thus, for ,
By using the Rigidity Theorem given in CD , we now define the isometries , , by
(3.6) |
Then, for ,
(3.7) |
where for . Moreover,
and
for and . Since for ,
where . Next, by condition (2) and Lemma 2.2, there is a multiplier with that satisfies
and a so that
where Then there exist invertible operators such that It then follows for some , that
(3.8) |
for all and . A direct calculation shows that for ,
3.3 Uniqueness of strongly irreducible decomposition up to similarity
When the Hilbert space is finite-dimensional, the Jordan canonical form theorem indicates that every operator on can be uniquely written as a direct sum of strongly irreducible operators up to similarity. Is there a corresponding analogue when one considers operators on an infinite-dimensional complex separable Hilbert space ? The notion of a unicellular operator was introduced in MSB1956 ; MSB1968 and it was shown in GEK1967-2 ; GEK1967 that dissipative operators can be written as a direct sum of unicellular operators. In BNF1979 ; BNF1975 ; NF1970 ; NF1970-3 ; NF1972 ; NF , every -operator on a complex separable Hilbert space was proven to be similar to a Jordan operator. Furthermore, in DH1990 , every bitriangular operator was shown to be quasisimilar to a Jordan operator. The concepts of strong irreducibility and of Banach irreducibility introduced in Gilfeather and JS2006 , respectively, turned out to be equivalent. In Halmos , the set of irreducible operators was proven to be dense in in the sense of Hilbert-Schmidt norm approximations. For the class , the work Y. Cao-J. S. Fang-C. L. Jiang CFJ2002 , C. L. Jiang J2004 , and C. L. Jiang-X. Z. Guo-K. Ji JGJ involve the -group of the commutant algebra as an invariant to show that an operator in has a unique strong irreducible decomposition up to similarity.
Let be an -hypercontraction. Denote by the Hilbert space of analytic functions on the unit disk with reproducing kernel for . The results in DKT and HJK show that is similar to the backward shift operator on if and only if there exists a bounded subharmonic function defined on such that
Note here that if , then .
We start with some definitions given in Gilfeather ; Halmos .
Definition 3.11.
Let be the commutant of . The operator is called strongly irreducible if does not have any nontrivial idempotents. It is called irreducible if does not any contain nontrivial self-adjoint idempotents.
Definition 3.12.
Consider , where is an analytic function space with reproducing kernel . Suppose that has a strongly irreducible decomposition, that is,
where each is strongly irreducible and for . It is said to have a unique strongly irreducible decomposition up to similarity, if for any operator that is similar to with a strongly irreducible decomposition
-
(1)
; and
-
(2)
there is a permutation on such that and .
Proposition 3.13.
Let , where is the adjoint of the operator of multiplication by on a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with reproducing kernel and is strongly irreducible for . Suppose that there exist an isometry and a Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle over for which condition holds such that
Then, there is a permutation on such that for
Proof: Note first that . By Lemma 3.4, we have
From CD , we also know that is congruent to . Moreover, an operator has an unique irreducible decomposition up to unitary equivalence as is shown in JJ . In CD , it is proven that operators in are unitary equivalent if and only if their holomorphic eigenvector bundles are equivalent. Since operators are strongly irreducible, there is a permutation on so that is congruent to , that is, there are unitary operators such that
Now since the complex bundle satisfies condition , we obtain from Theorem 3.5 an invertible operator with such that
Hence, the operator is invertible and
so that for
4 Applications of Theorem 3.2
Theorem 3.2 yields several sufficient conditions involving curvature for the similarity of certain adjoints of multiplication tuples. For , let be a bounded domain in . The space consists of functions defined on whose second order partial derivatives are continuous. The reader is referred to LAA ; PL ; KO for the following definitions and results.
Definition 4.1.
A function is said to be pluriharmonic if it satisfies the differential equations for
Definition 4.2.
A real-valued function is said to be plurisubharmonic if
-
(1)
is upper-semicontinuous on ; and
-
(2)
for each and some that is dependent on , the function is subharmonic with respect to .
Definition 4.3.
A non-negative function is called log-plurisubharmonic if the function is plurisubharmonic.
Lemma 4.4.
If is a pluriharmonic function on , then both and are plurisubharmonic functions on .
Lemma 4.5.
A real-valued function is plurisubharmonic if and only if for every .
Lemma 4.6.
Let be a convex function of two variables, increasing in each variable. If and are plurisubharmonic functions, then is also plurisubharmonic.
Lemma 4.7.
Let and be log-plurisubharmonic functions. Then is also log-plurisubharmonic.
Proof: Since the mapping is convex,
is also a convex function of two variables, increasing in each variable. Since and are plurisubharmonic, by Lemma 4.6,
is plurisubharmonic. Finally, we need the following definition of an n-hypercontraction given in MV1993 :
Definition 4.8.
Let be an -tuple of commuting operators. Define an operator by
An -tuple is called an -hypercontraction if
for all integers with . The special case of a -hypercontraction corresponds to the usual row contraction.
Note that since for all , one has
We now give a necessary and sufficient condition for the similarity of certain operator tuples in in terms of curvature and plurisubharmonic functions.
Theorem 4.9.
Let be an operator tuple on a Hilbert space with reproducing kernel where Consider on a weighted Bergman space with . Suppose that is -hypercontractive and that , for and an orthonormal basis for . Then if and only if there exists a bounded plurisubharmonic function such that
(4.1) |
Proof: If and are similar, then there is a bounded invertible operator such that If is a non-vanishing holomorphic section of , then is an non-vanishing holomorphic section of , and there are constants and such that
Since is pluriharmonic, Lemma 4.4 shows that is a bounded plurisubharmonic function.
For the converse, let and be non-vanishing holomorphic sections of and , respectively. Since
condition (4.1) gives
for all . Therefore, there exists a non-zero function such that
Since the function is bounded on , there exist constants and such that
(4.2) |
Note that since ,
where and denotes an orthonormal basis for . Since the reproducing kernel on a weighted Bergman space with satisfies , where , a direct calculation yields
Then,
Note that since and for every , when and otherwise. Moreover,
We next claim that there exists a constant such that for all
If not, then as so that by (4.2), as The maximum modulus principle would then imply that , a contradiction.
Finally, we have from Lemma 3.1 that where denotes the defect operator corresponding to and
for some unit vector . Using Theorem 3.2, we then conclude that .
The notion of curvature can also be used to describe the similarity of non-contractions as the following results show.
Proposition 4.10.
Let . Suppose that for , and
where is the operator of multiplication by on the Hardy space . Then but is not a contraction.
Proof: Set and Denote by an orthonormal basis for the space and define an operator as for . Let Then,
and therefore, is bounded. For a non-vanishing holomorphic section of , we have
This implies that and hence,
(4.3) |
The operator defined by is invertible and . Therefore, , and hence, .
Suppose now that is a contraction. For , set
Since for every ,
we have , that is, Then,
(4.4) |
Similarly, since for , it follows that for all
Therefore, for all
Then,
However, since
(4.5) |
Finally, by (4.3)–(4.5), it is easy to see that
This contradicts the result given in M that for a contraction , .
Corollary 4.11.
Let and denote by the operator of multiplication by on the Hardy space . Suppose that is such that for all , . If
then , but is not a contraction.
Corollary 4.12.
Let and denote by be the operator of multiplication by on the Hardy space . Suppose that is such that for all , If
then , but is not a contraction.
In the following theorem, we will use log-plurisubharmonic functions to give a sufficient condition for the similarity of tuples in . For an -tuple let
Theorem 4.13.
Let be such that . Suppose that
for some , where If there exists an integer satisfying for all , then , and . In particular, when , and are unitarily equivalent.
Now let be a non-vanishing holomorphic section of . Since and for some , we assume without loss of generality that . Then there exist bounded operators , such that
Define a linear operator as
for . Since
is a bounded linear operator. Furthermore, for any ,
Letting , we see that is invertible and that Hence, so that indeed, .
5 On the Cowen-Douglas conjecture
In CD , M. J. Cowen and R. G. Douglas proved that for , where , the curvature is a complete unitary invariant. Let and suppose that the closure of is a -spectral set for and . The Cowen-Douglas conjecture states that and are similar if and only if
Although the results of D. N. Clark and G. Misra in CM2 ; CM show that the Cowen-Douglas conjecture is false, the connection between similarity and properties of holomorphic vector bundles merits further investigation especially since a one-sided implication of the conjecture holds is some specific cases. We describe a class of operators in for which the Cowen-Douglas conjecture is true.
Example 5.1.
Let and for , consider on a weighted Bergman space with reproducing kernel . Suppose that where , and is a polynomial in . If condition holds for the Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle , then it follows from Lemma 3.4 and Theorem 3.5 that .
Now, a direct calculation shows that
Since is a polynomial in , is bounded above. Hence,
Remark 5.2.
One can consider and on a weighted Bergman space with to obtain an operator tuple analogue of Example 5.1. Under the same assumptions on , . Moreover, as
We next show that the Cowen-Douglas conjecture is false for tuples of commuting operators. As in CM , we construct operator tuples in for which the Cowen-Douglas conjecture holds; nevertheless, they are not similar. We begin with the following lemma given in HJX :
Lemma 5.3.
Let be -tuples of unilateral shift operators with nonzero weight sequences given by and , respectively. Then if and only if there exist constants and such that
for every , , and .
Example 5.4.
Consider the operator tuples on a reproducing kernel Hilbert space with reproducing kernel and on the Drury-Arveson space with reproducing kernel . To simplify the notation, we will set to be on while will denote the tuple on . Since ,
Now set and . Let and denote orthonormal bases for and , respectively. From the relation between reproducing kernels and weight sequences, we have
and
for and with in the -th position. Therefore, for every and ,
and by Lemma 5.3, and are not similar.
On the other hand, the definition of curvature yields
and
Then as ,
6 Further generalizations of single Cowen-Douglas operator results
In this section, we extend additional results given for a single Cowen-Douglas operator to a tuple of commuting operators.
6.1 Inequalities involving the trace of curvature
In M , G. Misra gave the curvature inequality for contractions in . Later in BKM , S. Biswas, D. K. Keshari, and G. Misra generalized the result and presented the following curvature matrix inequality for -tuples in :
Lemma 6.1.
Let be a row-contraction and consider on the Dury-Arveson space . Then for .
The above inequality implies that one can use the curvature matrix to determine whether a tuple of operators in is a row-contraction. We derive an analogous curvature matrix inequality for an -hypercontraction in . We first show that the trace of the curvature matrix for is independent of the choice of the holomorphic frame of .
Proposition 6.2.
Let . Suppose that and are holomorphic frames of . Then
for some invertible holomorphic matrix-valued function on .
Proof: Since and are holomorphic frames of , there is an invertible holomorphic matrix such that for all , Therefore,
Since is holomorphic and invertible,
This shows that is similar to and that
Thus, for all ,
In MV1993 , V. Müller and F.-H. Vasilescu gave the following description of when an -hypercontraction is unitarily equivalent to an adjoint of a multiplication tuple. Let denote the operator tuple on the space :
Lemma 6.3.
Let be an -tuple of commuting operators and let be a positive integer. Then there is a Hilbert space and an -invariant subspace of such that is unitarily equivalent to if and only if is an -hypercontraction with in the strong operator topology.
Another important tool for our work in the current section comes from the following result by D. K. Keshari in D :
Lemma 6.4.
Let be a Hermitian holomorphic vector bundle of rank over . Then the curvature matrices of the determinant bundle and of the vector bundle satisfy the equality
We now give a corresponding curvature inequality that holds for a -hypercontractive tuple in the class .
Theorem 6.5.
Let . For a -hypercontraction ,
where is on the space with reproducing kernel .
Proof: Since is a -hypercontraction, by Lemma 6.3, there exist a Hilbert space and an -invariant subspace such that . Let
If we denote by an orthonormal basis for then for every , , and ,
Hence, for every , , so that we can set . Then for all
Since we can assume that is a basis for and . Therefore,
and
Finally, since it is known from BKM that is negative definite, the proof is complete. We next show that the result of HJK holds for the multi-operator case as well. For , one defines a projection-valued function that assigns to each an orthogonal projection onto . Define an operator by
where Then, and
Theorem 6.6.
Let and let be an orthogonal projection onto . Then for
where denotes the Hilbert-Schmidt class of operators.
Proof: From we have for ,
Hence,
6.2 Final Remark
For , the Rosenblum operator is defined as
In Gilfeather , F. Gilfeather showed that an operator is strongly irreducible if there is no non-trivial idempotent in . The following relationship between strong irreducibility and the class is given in JJDG :
Lemma 6.7.
An operator is strongly irreducible if and only if
We conclude with an example illustrating the complexity of the similarity problem. It implies that the trace of the curvature matrix is not always a proper similarity invariant for the class . Let and be backward shift operators on Hilbert spaces and defined on the unit disk with reproducing kernels and , respectively.
Example 6.8.
Consider and . Suppose that
Let us first note that and . It can be easily checked that is a holomorphic frame of and that
It follows that Now by Lemma 6.4, we know that On the other hand, so that
Now, since , it follows from Lemma 6.7 that is strongly irreducible. Thus, has no non-trivial idempotent elements. If and were indeed similar, then there has to be an invertible operator such that . If we set then and is a non-trivial idempotent. However,
so that , and this is a contradiction. Hence, and are not similar.
7 Statements and Declarations
-
1.
Funding: The research leading to these results received funding from Hebei Normal University under Grant Agreement No. CXZZSS2019061 and from the National Science Foundation of China under Grant Agreement No. 11922108.
-
2.
Conflicts of Interest/Competing Interests: The authors have no relevant financial or non-financial interests to disclose.
References
- (1) Agler, J.: The Arveson extension theorem and coanalytic models. Integral Equations Operator Theory , 608-631 (1982). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01694057
- (2) Agler, J.: Hypercontractions and subnormality. J. Operator Theory (2), 203-217 (1985).
- (3) Agler, J., McCarthy, J.E.: Pick Interpolation and Hilbert Function Spaces. vol. 44 of Graduate Studies in Mathematics. American Mathematical Society. Providence, RI (2002). https://doi.org/10.1090/gsm/044
- (4) Aĭzenberg, L.A.: Pluriharmonic functions. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR , 967-969 (1959).
- (5) Ambrozie, C.-G., Engli, M., Mller, V.: Operator tuples and analytic models over general domains in . J. Operator Theory 47(2), 287-302 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1006/jnth.2001.2714
- (6) Arcozzi, N., Rochberg, R., Sawyer, E.: Carleson measures for the Drury-Arveson Hardy space and othe Besov-Sobolev spaces on complex balls. Adv. Math. (4), 1107-1180 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1016/J.AIM.2008.03.001
- (7) Athavale, A.: Holomorphic kernels and commuting operators. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. (1), 101-110 (1987). https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9947-1987-0906808-6
- (8) Athavale, A.: Model theory on the unit ball in . J. Operator Theory (2), 347-358 (1992). https://doi.org/10.2307/24714668
- (9) Ball, J.A., Trent, T.T., Vinnikov, V.: Interpolation and commutant lifting for multipliers on reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces. In: vol. 122 of Oper. Theory Adv. Appl. pp. 89-138. Birkhuser, Basel (2001). http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-0348-8283-54
- (10) Beatrous Jr., F.: Estimates for derivatives of holomorphic functions in pseudoconvex domains. Math. Z. (1), 91-116 (1986). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmaa.2006.06.090
- (11) Bercovici, H., Foiaş, C., Kérchy, L., Sz.-Nagy, B.: Compléments à l’étude des opérateurs de classe . IV. Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) (1)(2), 29-31 (1979).
- (12) Bercovici, H., Sz.-Nagy, B., Foiaş, C.: Compléments à l’étude des opérateurs de classe . III. Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) (3)(4), 313-322 (1975).
- (13) Biswas, S., Keshari, D.K., Misra, G.: Infinitely divisible metrics and curvature inequalities for operators in the Cowen-Douglas class. J. Lond. Math. Soc. (2), 941-956 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1112/jlms/jdt045
- (14) Brodskiĭ, M.S.: On Jordan cells of infinite-dimensional operators. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR , 926-929 (1956).
- (15) Brodskiĭ, M.S.: Decomposition of a dissipative operator with an imaginary kernel component into unicellular operators. Funct. Anal. Appl. (3), 254-256 (1968). https://doi.org/10.1007/bf01076127
- (16) Cao, Y., Fang, J.S., Jiang, C.L.: K-groups of Banach algebras and strongly irreducible decompositions of operators. J. Operator Theory (2), 235-253 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1007/bfb0071311
- (17) Carleson, L.: Interpolations by bounded analytic functions and the corona problem. Ann. of Math. (2), 547-559 (1962). https://doi.org/10.2307/1970375
- (18) Clark, D.N., Misra, G.: On curvature and similarity. Michigan Math. J. (3), 361-367 (1983). https://doi.org/10.1307/mmj/1029002911
- (19) Clark, D.N., Misra, G.: On weighted shifts, curvature, and similarity. J. Lond. Math. Soc. (2), 357-368 (1985). https://doi.org/10.1112/jlms/s2-31.2.357
- (20) Cowen, M.J., Douglas, R.G.: Complex geometry and operator theory. Acta. Math. (1), 187-261 (1978). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02545748
- (21) Cowen, M.J., Douglas, R.G.: Operators possessing an open set of eigenvalues. In: Functions, Series, Operators, Vol. I, II (Budapest, 1980); vol. 35 of Colloq. Math. Soc. János Bolyai, pp. 323-341. North-Holland, Amsterdam (1983).
- (22) Cowen, M.J., Douglas, R.G.: Equivalence of connections. Adv. Math. (1), 39-91 (1985). https://doi.org/10.1016/0001-8708(85)90084-2
- (23) Curto, R.E., Salinas, N.: Generalized Bergman kernels and the Cowen-Douglas theory. Amer. J. Math. (2), 447-488 (1984). https://doi.org/10.2307/2374310
- (24) Curto, R.E., Vasilescu, F.H.: Standard operator models in the polydisc. Indiana Univ. Math. J. (3), 791-810 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1512/iumj.1993.42.42035
- (25) Curto, R.E., Vasilescu. F.H.: Standard operator models in the polydisc. II. Indiana Univ. Math. J. (3), 727-746 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1512/iumj.1995.44.2005
- (26) Davidson, K.R., Herrero, D.A.: The Jordan form of a bitriangular operator. J. Funct. Anal. (1), 27-73 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-1236(90)90027-I
- (27) Douglas, R.G., Kwon, H.K., Treil, S: Similarity of -hypercontractions and backward Bergman shifts. J. Lond. Math. Soc. (3), 637-648 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1112/jlms/jdt035
- (28) Eschmeier, J., Putinar, M.: Spherical contractions and interpolation problems on the unit ball. J. Reine Angew. Math. , 219-236 (2002). http://dx.doi.org/10.1515/crll.2002.007
- (29) Fuhrmann, P.A.: On the corona theorem and its application to spectral problems in Hilbert space. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. , 55-66 (1968). https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9947-1968-0222701-7
- (30) Gilfeather, F.: Strong reducibility of operators. Indiana Univ. Math. J. (4), 393-397 (1972). https://dx.doi.org/10.1512/iumj.1973.22.22032
- (31) Halmos, P.R.: Irreducible operators. Michigan Math. J. , 215-223 (1968). https://doi.org/10.1307/mmj/1028999975
- (32) Hartz, M.: An invitation to the Drury-Arveson space. Preprint at https://arxiv.org/abs/2204.01559 (2022).
- (33) Hörmander, L.: Generators for some rings of analytic functions. Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. , 943-949 (1967). https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9904-1967-11860-3
- (34) Hou, Y.L., Ji, K., Ji, S.S., Xu, J.: Geometry of holomorphic vector bundles and similarity of commuting operator tuples. Preprint at https://arxiv.org/abs/1801.01680 (2018).
- (35) Hou, Y.L., Ji. K., Kwon, H.K.: The trace of the curvature determines similarity. Studia Math. (2), 193-200 (2017). https://doi.org/10.4064/sm8588-9-2016
- (36) Hou, Y.L., Ji, S.S., Xu, J.: On the -hypercontractions and similarity of multivariable weighted shifts. Preprint at https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.08387 (2022).
- (37) Ji, K., Ji, S.S.: A note on unitary equivalence of operators acting on reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces. Preprint at https://arxiv.org/abs/2111.15011 (2022).
- (38) Ji, K., Jiang, C.L., Keshari, D.K., Misra, G.: Rigidity of the flag structure for a class of Cowen-Douglas operators. J. Funct. Anal. (7), 2899-2932 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfa.2016.12.019
- (39) Ji, K., Kwon, H.K., Sarkar, J., Xu, J.: A subclass of the Cowen-Douglas class and similarity. Math. Nachr. (11), 2197-2222 (2022). http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/mana.202000326
- (40) Ji, K., Sarkar, J.: Similarity of quotient Hilbert modules in the Cowen-Douglas class. Eur. J. Math. (4), 1331-1351 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/S40879-018-0297-Y
- (41) Jiang, C.L.: Similarity classification of Cowen-Douglas operators. Canad. J. Math. (4), 742-775 (2004). https://doi.org/10.4153/CJM-2004-034-8
- (42) Jiang, C.L., Guo, X.Z., Ji, K.: K-group and similarity classification of operators. J. Funct. Anal. (1), 167-192 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfa.2004.12.008
- (43) Jiang, C.L., Ji, K.: Similarity classification of holomorphic curves. Adv. Math. , 446-468 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aim.2007.03.015
- (44) Jiang, C.L., Ji, K., Keshari, D.K.: Geometric similarity invariants of Cowen-Douglas operators. Preprint at https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.03993 (2019).
- (45) Jiang, Z.J., Sun, S.L.: On completely irreducible operators. Translated from Acta Sci. Natur. Univ. Jilin (1992); Front. Math. China (4), 569-581 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11464-006-0028-4
- (46) Keshari, D.K.: Trace formulae for curvature of jet bundles over planar domains. Complex Anal. Oper. Theory (8), 1723-1740 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11785-014-0361-7
- (47) Kisilevs’kiĭ, G.È.: Cyclic subspaces of dissipative operators. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR , 1006-1009 (1967). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-0348-8789-212
- (48) Kisilevs’kiĭ, G.È.: A generalization of the Jordan theory to a certain class of linear operators in Hilbert space. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR , 768-770 (1967). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0016-5085(08)80553-7
- (49) Kwon, H.K.: Similarity to the backward shift operator on the Dirichlet space. J. Operator Theory (1), 133-140 (2016). https://doi.org/10.7900/jot.2015sep19.2079
- (50) Kwon, H.K., Treil, S.: Similarity of operators and geometry of eigenvector bundles. Publ. Mat. (2), 417-438 (2009). https://doi.org/10.5565/PUBLMAT5320906
- (51) Lelong, P.: Les fonctions plurisousharmoniques. Ann. Sci. Éc. Norm. Supér. (3), 301-338 (1945). https://doi.org/10.24033/asens.927
- (52) Lin, Q.: Operator theoretical realization of some geometric notions. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. (1), 353-367 (1988). https://doi.org/10.2307/2001057
- (53) Luo, S.B.: Corona theorem for the Dirichlet-type space. J. Geom. Anal. : Article No. 74 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12220-021-00814-x
- (54) Misra, G.: Curvature inequalities and extremal properties of bundle shifts. J. Operator Theory (2), 305-317 (1984).
- (55) Müller, V.: Models for operators using weighted shifts. J. Operator Theory (1), 3-20 (1988).
- (56) Müller, V., Vasilescu, F.H.: Standard models for some commuting multioperators. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. (4), 979-989 (1993). https://doi.org/10.2307/2159525
- (57) Nikolski, N.K.: Treatise on the Shift Operator. vol. 273 of Grundlehren der Mathematischen Wissenschaften [Fundamental Principles of Mathematical Sciences], Spectral Function Theory. Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1986). With an appendix by S.V. Hruščev [S.V. Khrushchëv] and V.V. Peller. Translated from the Russian by Jaak Peetre. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-70151-1
- (58) Nikolski, N.K.: Operators, Functions, and Systems: an Easy Reading, Vol. 1: Hardy, Hankel, and Toeplitz. Vol. 92 of Mathematical surveys and monographs. Amer. Math. Soc. Providence, RI (2002). Translated from the French by Andreas Hartmann. http://dx.doi.org/10.1090/surv/092
- (59) Oka, K.: Sur les fonctions analytiques de plusieurs variables. VI., Domaines pseudoconvexes. Tohoku Math. J. , 15-52 (1942).
- (60) Pearcy, C.: A complete set of unitary invariants for operators generating finite -algebras of type I. Pacific J. Math. , 1405-1416 (1962). http://dx.doi.org/10.2140/pjm.1962.12.1405
- (61) Pott, S.: Standard models under polynomial positivity conditions. J. Operator Theory (2), 365-389 (1999).
- (62) Rosenblum, M.: A corona theorem for countably many functions. Integral Equations Operator Theory (1), 125-137 (1980). https://doi.org/10.1007/bf01682874
- (63) Specht, W.: Zur Theorie der Matrizen II. Iber. Deutsch. Math. Verein. , 19-23 (1940).
- (64) Sz.-Nagy, B., Foiaş, C.: Modèle de Jordan pour une classe de l’espace de Hilbert. Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) , 91-115 (1970).
- (65) Sz.-Nagy, B., Foiaş, C.: Compléments à l’étude des opérateurs de classe . Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) 287-296 (1970).
- (66) Sz.-Nagy, B., Foiaş, C.: Compléments à l’étude des opérateurs de classe . II., Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) 113-116 (1972).
- (67) Sz.-Nagy, B., Foiaş, C.: The function model of a contraction and the space . Acta Sci. Math. (Szeged) 403-410 (1979). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00125-015-3621-9
- (68) Tolokonnikov, V.A.: Estimates in Carleson’s corona theorem and finitely generated ideals of the algebra H∞. Funktsional. Anal. i Prilozhen. (4), 85-86 (1980). https://doi.org/10.1007/bf01078318
- (69) Tolokonnikov, V.A.: Estimates in the Carleson corona theorem, ideals of the algebra , a problem of Sz.-Nagy. In: Investigations on Linear Operators and the Theory of Functions, XI. In vol. 113 of Zap. Nauchn. Sem. Leningrad. Otdel. Mat. Inst. Steklov. (LOMI) pp. 178-198 (1981). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01882580
- (70) Treil, S.R.: Angles between co-invariant subspaces, and the operator corona problem. The Szőkefalvi-Nagy problem. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR (5), 1063-1068 (1988).
- (71) Trent, T.T.: A new estimate for the vector valued corona problem. J. Funct. Anal. (1), 267-282 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1006/jfan.2001.3842
- (72) Uchiyama, A.: Corona theorems for countably many functions and estimates for their solutions. Preprint, UCLA (1980).
- (73) Uchiyama, M.: Curvatures and similarity of operators with holomorphic eigenvectors. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. (1), 405-415 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1090/s0002-9947-1990-0968421-4
- (74) Varopoulos, N.Th.: BMO functions and the -equation. Pacific J. Math. (1), 221-273 (1977).
- (75) Vasilescu, F.H.: An operator-valued Poisson kernel. J. Funct. Anal. (1), 47-72 (1992). https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-1236(92)90042-H
- (76) Zhao, R., Zhu, K.: Theory of Bergman spaces in the unit ball of . Mm. Soc. Math. Fr. (2008). https://doi.org/10.24033/msmf.427