The algebra of conjugacy classes of the wreath product
of a finite group with the symmetric group
Abstract.
For a finite group we define the concept of -partial permutation and use it to show that the structure coefficients of the center of the wreath product algebra are polynomials in with non-negative integer coefficients. Our main tool is a combinatorial algebra which projects onto the center of the group algebra for every This generalizes the Ivanov and Kerov method to prove the polynomiality property for the structure coefficients of the center of the symmetric group algebra.
Key words and phrases:
Wreath product, partial permutations, structure coefficients, character theory, shifted symmetric functions2020 Mathematics Subject Classification:
Primary 05E05, 05E10, 20C30; Secondary 20E22.1. Introduction
Throughout this paper will be a finite group, its identity element, its set of conjugacy classes and its set of irreducible complex characters. If is a positive integer, let denote the symmetric group on the set A partition is a finite list of non-increasing positive integers called parts. The size of a partition is the sum of all of its parts. A partition of size is usually called a partition of We denote by the set of families of partitions indexed by such that the sizes of the partitions sum up to The type of an element of the wreath product is a family of partitions see [5]. Two elements of are conjugate if and only if they have the same type. The center of the group algebra, which will be denoted is the algebra over generated by the conjugacy classes of If we define to be the formal sum of all the elements in with type The family indexed by is a linear basis for The structure coefficients are the non-negative integers defined by the following product in
In the case where is the trivial group, the group is isomorphic to the symmetric group The conjugacy classes of are indexed by partitions of It is a difficult problem to find explicit formulas even for particular structure coefficients of see [4], [2], [11]. In [1], Farahat and Higman showed that the structure coefficients of are polynomials in By introducing partial permutations in [3], Ivanov and Kerov gave a combinatorial proof to this result. Recently, we used in [10] our general framework developed in [9] to show a polynomiality property for the structure coefficients of
Beside from being combinatorial, the Ivanov-Kerov approach, developed in [3], uses a universal algebra which turns out to be isomorphic to the algebra of shifted symmetric functions. In the past few years, it was used to show a polynomiality property for the structure coefficients of some interesting algebras. For example, we define the notion of partial bijection in [8] to show that the structure coefficients of the Hecke algebra of the pair where is the hyperoctahedral subgroup of are polynomials in In [6], the concept of partial isomorphism appeared to give a polynomiality property for the structure coefficients of the center of the group algebra, where is a prime number and is the group of invertible matrices with coefficients in the finite field We used the notion of -partial permutation in [12] to give a more combinatorial proof to our result in [10].
In [13], Wang proved that the structure coefficients of are polynomials in He used the Farahat-Higman approach developed in [1] for the center of the symmetric group algebra. The goal of this paper is to generalize the Ivanov-Kerov approach in order to obtain Wangโs result by a more algebraic combinatorial way. For this reason, we will define the concept of -partial permutation and use it to build a universal combinatorial algebra which projects onto the center of the group algebra for each We will prove that this universal algebra is isomorphic to the algebra of shifted symmetric functions on alphabets. Recently, it came to our attention that Wang mentioned our generalization in [14, Section ]. However, in addition to providing all the details, we think that some presented results like Theorem 7.1, are new and make a valuable contribution to the literature.
The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, we present the necessary definitions for partitions and we review some basic results concerning the conjugacy classes and the center of the group algebra. Then, in Section 3, we introduce the notion of -partial permutation. An action of the group on the set of -partial permutations of is given in Section 4. The universal combinatorial algebra which projects on the center of the group algebra for each will be built in Section 5. Next in Section 6, we prove in Theorem 6.2 that the structure coefficients of the center of the group algebra are polynomials in In the last section, we present an isomorphism between and the algebra of shifted symmetric functions on alphabets.
2. Algebra of the conjugacy classes of
In this section we will review all necessary definitions and results concerning the conjugacy classes of For more details, the reader is invited to check [5, Appendix B].
2.1. Partitions
A partition is a weakly decreasing list of positive integers The are called the parts of The size of denoted by is the sum of all of its parts. We say that is a partition of if The set of all partitions of will be denoted In this paper, we will mainly use the exponential notation where is the number of parts equal to in the partition We will dismiss from when for example, we will write instead of If and are two partitions, we define the union and subtraction (if exists) as the following partitions:
The cycle-type of a permutation of is the partition of obtained from the lengthes of the cycles that appear in its decomposition into product of disjoint cycles. For example, the permutation of has cycle-type It is well known that two permutations of belong to the same conjugacy class if and only if they have the same cycle-type. Thus the conjugacy classes of can be indexed by partitions of The conjugacy class of associated to the partition will be denoted and its cardinal is given by the following formula:
where
A partition is called proper if it does not have any part equal to 1. The proper partition associated to a partition is the partition The set of all proper partitions with size less than or equal to will be denoted If is a partition of we can extend to a partition of by adding parts equal to one, the new partition of will be denoted
If is a finite set and is a family of partitions indexed by we define the size of denoted by to be the sum of the sizes of
The set of families of partitions of size indexed by will be denoted and will denote the set of families of partitions indexed by with size less than or equal to In this paper we will mainly encounter families of partitions indexed by and An element is called proper if the partition is proper. We will use (resp. ) to denote the set of proper families of partitions of size (resp. less than or equal to ) indexed by If we define to be the element of with if and
2.2. Conjugacy classes of
The wreath product is the group with underlying set and product defined as follows:
for any We apply before when we write the product The identity in this group is The inverse of an element is given by
Let where and is written as a product of disjoint cycles. If is a cycle of the element is determined up to conjugacy in by and and is called the cycle product of corresponding to the cycle see [5, Page ]. For any conjugacy class we denote by the partition written in the exponential way where is the number of cycles of length in whose cycle-product lies in for each integer Then each element gives rise to a family of partitions indexed by such that
This family of partitions is called the type of and denoted
Example 2.1.
When the type of is a -vector of partitions where each partition is formed out of cycles of whose cycle product equals For example, consider the element where and The cycle product of is of is of is of is and of is in Thus with and
It turns out, see [5, Page ], that two permutations are conjugate in if and only if they have the same type. Thus the conjugacy classes of can be indexed by the elements of If we will denote by its associated conjugacy class:
From [5, (3.1)], the order of the centralizer of an element of type in is
where is the order of the centralizer of an element in Thus, if the cardinal of is given by:
2.3. The center of the group algebra
The group algebra of denoted by is the algebra over with basis the elements of the group The product in is the linear extension of the group product in The center of the group algebra usually denoted by is the sub-algebra of of invariant elements under the conjugation action of on
The conjugacy classes of index a basis of We showed in Section 2.2 that the conjugacy classes of are indexed by the elements of Thus, the family where
forms a linear basis for Let and be two elements of the structure coefficients of the algebra are defined by the following equation:
(1) |
The coefficients are non-negative integer since they count the number of pairs of elements such that for a fixed element However, it is a very hard problem to compute these coefficients even in particular cases. For instance, the easiest choice for is the trivial group in which the group is isomorphic to There is no explicit formula to compute all the structure coefficients of the center of the symmetric group algebra. Explicit formulas for particular structure coefficients of appeared in many papers, for example see [4], [2] and [11].
In [1], Farahat and Higman showed that the structure coefficients of are polynomials in which was later proved by Ivanov and Kerov in [3] using a more combinatorial way. In [13], following the Farahat and Higman approach, Wang proved that the structure coefficients of are polynomials in In the next sections we will develop a combinatorial approach in order to prove Wangโs result using the Ivanov-Kerov method.
3. -partial permutations
A partial permutation of is a pair consisting of an arbitrary subset of and an arbitrary bijection The notion of partial permutation of appeared in [3] to show by a combinatorial way that the structure coefficients of the center of the symmetric group algebra are polynomials in
If is a subset of we denote by the set of vectors with -coordinates such that if and is left blank otherwise. For example, if and then but
Definition 3.1.
A -partial permutation of is a pair where is a partial permutation of and
We denote by the set of all -partial permutations of It would be clear that
A -partial permutation of may be represented by a diagram obtained by drawing the two lines permutation diagram associated to with the nodes of the bottom row replaced by the elements for This representation will help us understanding the product between -partial permutations of which will be defined later.
Example 3.2.
If and then we represent the element by the following diagram
The definition of type can be extended naturally to a -partial permutation of If is a -partial permutation of and then let be the partition written in the exponential way where is the number of cycles of length in whose cycle-product lies in for each integer Define the type of to be the family of partitions indexed by It would be clear that
If we denote by the element of where and are defined by:
The product of two -partial permutations and of is defined by:
where
This product is well defined since is a partial permutation of The set is a semigroup with this multiplication. The unity in is the -partial permutation where is the trivial permutation of the empty set We denote by the algebra of the semigroup
Example 3.3.
Reconsider the -partial permutation of Example 3.2 and let be the -partial permutation of with and then the product yields the following -partial permutation of
This can be obtained easily by drawing the diagram of above the diagram of then extending both of them to as represented below
All extensions are drawn in red. The diagram of the product is then obtained by taking the resulted diagram of the above combination
4. Action of on
Any element of the wreath product can be seen as a -partial permutation of by identifying with the partial permutation The wreath product acts on the semigroup by:
where if for any and The orbits of this action will be called the conjugacy classes of Two -partial permutations and of are in the same conjugacy class if and only if there exists such that that is and for any
Example 4.1.
Let and To obtain that
we have to draw the diagram of restricted to then below it the diagram of then below it the diagram of restricted to as shown below
Then it would be easy to verify that since the cycle product of the cycle of is conjugate to the cycle product of the cycle of and the cycle product of the cycle of is conjugate to the cycle product of the cycle of
This shows that the conjugacy classes of can be indexed by the elements of the set of families of partitions indexed by with size less than or equal to If the conjugacy class of associated to will be denoted and is defined by:
Proposition 4.2.
If then:
Proof.
Consider the following mapping
If with we have which implies that
(2) |
Let and consider the set defined as follows:
Since has type then it would be clear that To make an element must coincide with on which necessarily implies that and we choose fixed points for among the fixed points of Thus for any we have
Combining this formula with Equation (2) ends the proof. โ
We extend the action of on by linearity to an action on the algebra of the semigroup and we denote
the sub-algebra of invariant elements under this action.
Proposition 4.3.
The surjective homomorphism
is compatible with the action of on
Proof.
We need to prove that for any and any we have:
We have where if which implies that with
On the other hand with If then which implies that and which results in If then Thus and it is easy to check that which ends the proof. โ
The surjective homomorphism can be extended to a surjective homomorphism of algebras and Proposition 4.3 implies that
If let us denote by the following formal sum:
The elements of the family form a basis for the algebra and if then by Proposition 4.2 we have:
(3) |
5. Action of on
Denote by the projective limit of the algebras with respect to the homomorphism defined by:
If is a finite subset of we define to be the set of vectors with infinite number of coordinates such that whenever and is left blank otherwise. An element can be canonically written:
where the โs are complex numbers. Consider the group of permutations of with finite support. Let the group acts on by conjugation and denote by the sub-algebra of invariant elements of under this action. An element is in if and only if:
where if and is left blank if
Definition 5.1.
A -partial permutation of is a pair where is a finite subset of and
We denote by the set of all -partial permutations of For a family of partitions indexed by we define as follows:
Any element in can be written in a unique way as an infinite linear combination of elements where
Let and be two families of partitions in the structure coefficients of the algebra are defined by:
(4) |
Proposition 5.2.
The function defined by for any is a filtration on
Proof.
We need to prove that for any two families of partitions For this let be a family of partitions in for which of Equation (4) is a non-zero coefficient. By its definition, counts the number of pairs of -partial permutations such that
where is a fixed -partial permutation belonging to It would be then sufficient to remark that, when multiplying by the permutation acts on at most elements. This means that each family of partitions that appears in the sum of Equation (4) must satisfy
(5) |
which ends the proof. โ
Remark 5.3.
More filtrations on may exist as suggested by [3]. In this paper, we will only use the above proved one.
We denote by the natural projection homomorphism between and defined on the generating element of by
If then we have:
By Equation (4), are also the structure coefficients of the algebra
where and are two families of partitions belonging to In other words, the structure coefficients of do not depend on and they are the structure coefficients of for any
6. Polynomiality of the structure coefficients of
In this section we will prove our main result in Theorem 6.2. For this we will need the following lemma.
Lemma 6.1.
If then we have for any where is the family of partitions of size indexed by and defined by and if
Theorem 6.2.
Let and be three proper families of partitions indexed by and let be a natural number with The structure coefficient is a polynomial in with degree that can be written:
where the coefficients are independant integers of
Proof.
Example 6.3.
Let be a prime number and consider Recall that the type of is a -vector of partitions where each partition is formed out of cycles of whose cycle product equals If and is a partition then we denote by the -vector of partitions where and if If is a proper partition then it would be clear that is a proper family of partitions. We have:
where is the vector with infinite number of coordinates such that and is left blank if It would be clear that is proper if and only if Suppose that then we have
This can be deduced by drawing the multiplication diagram as below:
In addition, we have:
where the sum is taken modulo Thus, if then
(6) |
where is the -vector of partitions with and if The coefficient of in the right hand side of Equation (6) is due to the fact that both products and yields the same -partial permutation If by applying then on Equation (6) we obtain:
and
7. Irreducible characters of and symmetric functions
In this section we will recall all the necessary definitions and results from the theory of summetric functions in order to prove that the algebra is isomorphic to an algebra of shifted symmetric functions on alphabets.
7.1. The case
When the wreath product is isomorphic to the symmetric group The irreducible -modules are indexed by partitions of If we will denote by its associated irreducible -module and by its character. It is well known that both the power sum functions and the Schur functions indexed by partitions, are basis families for the algebra of symmetric functions. The transition matrix between these two bases is given by the following formula of Frobenius:
(7) |
where denotes the value of the character on any permutation of cycle-type
A shifted symmetric function in infinitely many variables is a family that satisfies the following two properties:
-
1.
is a symmetric polynomial in
-
2.
The set of all shifted symmetric functions is an algebra which we shall denote In [7], Okounkov and Olshanski gave a linear isomorphism For any partition the images of the power sum function and the Schur function by are the shifted power symmetric function and the shifted Schur function By applying to the Frobenius relation given in Equation (7), we get:
(8) |
If and if is a partition, we denote by the value By [7], any shifted symmetric function is determined by its values on partitions. The vanishing characterization of the shifted symmetric functions given in [7] states that is the unique shifted symmetric function of degree at most such that
(9) |
where is the falling factorial and is the number of skew standard tableaux of shape Using the following branching rule for characters of the symmetric groups
(10) |
one can verify using formulas (8) and (9) that
Using this formula, Ivanov and Kerov showed in [3, Theorem 9.1] that the mapping defined on the basis elements of by
is an isomorphism of algebras.
7.2. The general case
We refer to [5, Appendix B] for the results of the representation theory of wreath products presented in this section. Let be a family of independent indeterminates over For each we may think of as the power sum in a sequence of variables Let us denote by the algebra over with algebraic basis the elements
If is an arbitrary partition and we define to be the product of
The family where
forms a linear basis for That is any element can be written where all but a finite number of the coefficients are zero. If we assign degree to then
is a graded -algebra where is the algebra spanned by all where The algebra can be equipped with a hermitian scalar product defined by
for any two elements and of In particular, we have:
where is the Kronecker symbol.
For each irreducible character and each let
where is the value of the character on an element of the conjugacy class By the orthogonality of the characters of
we can write
We may think of as the power sum in a new sequence of variables and denote by the schur function associated to the partition on the sequence of variables Now, for any family of partitions define
The family is an orthonormal basis of see [5, (7.4)].
Let be the irreducible -module associated to The group acts on the tensor power as follows:
where and Let us denote by the character of this representation of From [5, (8.2)], if has type then:
For any partition of and each we define
We can extend this definition to families of partitions If let
The family is a full list of irreducible characters of For any two families of partitions and let us denote by the value of the character on any of the elements of the conjugacy class By [5, page 177], we have the following three important identities
and
Let us consider the algebra isomorphic to defined using the shifted symmetric functions. It has a basis formed by the shifted functions defined by
for any For any family of partitions we set
Theorem 7.1.
The linear map defined by
is an isomorphism of algebras.
Proof.
Let and consider the composition of morphisms. Let us see how acts on the basis elements of If with it would be clear then that Suppose now that we have the following equalities:
โ
References
- [1] H.ย Farahat and G.ย Higman. The centres of symmetric group rings. Proc. Roy. Soc. (A), 250:212โ221, 1959.
- [2] A.ย Goupil and G.ย Schaeffer. Factoring n-cycles and counting maps of given genus. Eur. J. Comb., 19(7):819โ834, 1998.
- [3] V.ย Ivanov and S.ย Kerov. The algebra of conjugacy classes in symmetric groups, and partial permutations. Zap. Nauchn. Sem. S.-Peterburg. Otdel. Mat. Inst. Steklov. (POMI), 256(3):95โ120, 1999.
- [4] J.ย Katriel and J.ย Paldus. Explicit expression for the product of the class of transpositions with an arbitrary class of the symmetric group. Group Theoretical Methods in Physics, pages 503โ506, 1987.
- [5] I.ย Macdonald. Symmetric functions and Hall polynomials. Oxford Univ. Press, second edition, 1995.
- [6] P.-L. Mรฉliot. Partial isomorphisms over finite fields. Journal of Algebraic Combinatorics, 40(1):83โ136, 2014.
- [7] A.ย Y. Okounkov and G.ย I. Olshanskii. Shifted schur functions. Algebra i Analiz, 9(2):73โ146, 1997.
- [8] O.ย Tout. Structure coefficients of the hecke algebra of . The Electronic Journal of Combinatorics, 21(4):P4โ35, 2014.
- [9] O.ย Tout. A general framework for the polynomiality property of the structure coefficients of double-class algebras. Journal of Algebraic Combinatorics, 45(4):1111โ1152, June 2017.
- [10] O.ย Tout. The center of the wreath product of symmetric groups algebra. To appear in Algebra and Discrete Mathematics, 2019.
- [11] O.ย Tout. Some explicit expressions for the structure coefficients of the center of the symmetric group algebra involving cycles of length three. Journal of Algebra Combinatorics Discrete Structures and Applications, 6(2):53โ62, 2019.
- [12] O.ย Tout. -partial permutations and the center of the wreath product algebra. Journal of Algebraic Combinatorics, pages 1โ24, 2020.
- [13] W.ย Wang. The FarahatโHigman ring of wreath products and Hilbert schemes. Advances in Mathematics, 187(2):417โ446, 2004.
- [14] W.ย Wang. Vertex algebras and the class algebras of wreath products. Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society, 88(2):381โ404, 2004.