On the topology of the Milnor boundary for real analytic singularities
Abstract.
We study the topology of the boundaries of the Milnor fibers of real analytics map-germs and that admit Milnor’s tube fibrations, where is the canonical projection for For each we prove that the Milnor boundary is given by the double of the Milnor tube fiber We prove that if , then the pair is a generalized -open-book decomposition with binding and page - the interior of the Milnor fibre (see the definition below). This allows us to prove several new Euler characteristic formulae connecting the Milnor boundaries with the respectives links for each and a Lê-Greuel type formula for the Milnor boundary.
1. Introduction
One of the most active and challenging areas in singularity theory is the study of non-isolated singularities of complex spaces. For instance, if is a holomorphic germ of function with non-isolated critical point, the degeneration process of the non-critical levels to the non-isolated singularity hypersurface defined by is still not well-understood, unlike the isolated singularity case.
One approach to this problem is to study such degeneration over a small sphere around the origin. In other words, one tries to understand the topology of the boundary of the Milnor fiber and how it degenerates to the link of . This problem has been attacked by several authors like Siersma [40, 41], Nemethi-Szilard [33], Michel-Pichon [29, 30, 31], Bobadilla-Menegon [16], Menegon-Seade [28] and Aguilar-Menegon-Seade [1].
The corresponding understanding for real analytic singularities is still very poor. Although one can define a Milnor fibration for many classes of real analytic germs of mapping , not much is known about the topology of the corresponding Milnor fiber or the link of (see [34, 20, 28, 25, 21] for some results), and even less about the boundary of such objects.
The first part of this paper aims to introduce a new perspective to deal with such problem, inspired mainly by [14, 3, 27]. The idea is to relate the topology of the boundary of the Milnor fiber of , denoted by , with the boundary of the Milnor fiber of the composition of with some projection , which we denote by . As a result, in Section 3 we prove that for there is a generalized open-book decomposition
where is the composition of with the projection . The particular case and the case of a complex ICIS are analyzed.
On the other hand, the understanding of the topology of the boundary of the Milnor fiber of the function-germ also provides a tool to better understanding the topology of the Milnor fiber of the map-germ itself. In fact, in Section 4 we use the aforementioned open-book decomposition to obtain some formulae relating the Euler characteristics of , and the link of , for .
Finally, in the last section of the article we use those Euler characteristic formulae to get a hint on the possible topological behaviour of real analytic map-germs on an odd number of variables and how similar or different it can be when compared with the complex setting.
2. Notations and basics definitions
Let be an analytic map germ and consider the following diagram
(1) |
where the projections and and
Basic notations and definitions:
The zero locus of is defined and denoted by respectively, and Hence,
The singular set of , denoted by , is defined to be the set of points such that the rank of the Jacobian matrix is lower than . Analogously, we define the singular sets and of and , respectively. The discriminant set of is then defined by
The polar set of relative to is defined and denoted by . Analogously, we define and .
The next diagram relates the singular and the polar sets:
(2) |
Definition 2.1.
We say that a map germ is tame, or satisfies the transversality condition at the origin if
as a germ of set at the origin.
Lemma 2.2.
Let If is tame, then and are tame as well.
It is well known that the tameness conditions for and induce the following fibrations on the boundary of the closed ball :
(3) |
(4) |
(5) |
Moreover, under the extra conditions there also exists the Milnor tube’s fibration is the following sense: there exists small enough such that for all there exists such that the restriction map
(6) |
is a locally trivial smooth fibration, where respectively stand for the closed ball in with radius centered at origin, respectively in with radius
Hence, for the same reason, we conclude the existence of the Milnor tube fibrations for and
(7) |
(8) |
From now on denote by , and the Milnor fibers of the fibrations (6), (7) and (8), respectively, by , and the fibers of (3), (4) and (5).
Consider the Milnor tube fibration and Thus the fiber
Denote by the dimensional closed disc given by the intersection of the fiber of projection with the closed ball on the target space of fibration (6).
Thus and one may consider the restriction map which is a smooth surjective proper submersion, and hence a smooth trivial fibration.
Therefore, the following homeomorphism follows which is a diffeomorphism after smoothing the corners. On the boundary of the Milnor fiber the following diffeomorphism holds true:
(9) |
We remark that the next Proposition is in the same vein as [12, Corollary 4].
Proposition 2.3.
Let be a tame map germ with and for consider the composition map where is the projection map. Then the boundary of the Milnor fiber is obtained (up to homeomorphism) by the gluing together two disjoint copies of the Milnor fiber along the common boundary
Proof.
The proof follows from the composition
where and the fact that being tame implies the same to and In the same manner implies ,
Hence, and the boundary
(10) |

Now it is easy to see that the closed manifold is obtained by the gluing the two disjoint copies of given by along the boundaries of the cylinder See the Figure (1). Therefore the result follows. ∎
3. Fibration structure on the boundary of the Milnor fiber
From now on we will consider tame, and One may adjust the radii and in the fibrations (3), (4) and (5) such that and the restriction map is well defined, for any
Lemma 3.1.
The restriction map is a smooth submersion.
Proof.
For consider and the matrix
By the tameness of we have that for all the rank of is maximal. Hence is a smooth submersion. ∎
Now since is a regular value of by the compactness of one may choose small enough and a closed disc centered at the origin such that all is a regular value of the restriction map
Hence the restriction map is a smooth onto submersion, then a trivial fibration with the fiber diffeomorphic to Therefore,
(11) |
Denote by the closed tubular neighbourhood of the embedded submanifold See the Figure (2).

Then, by (9) it follows that the complement
(12) |
In this section we will prove that the embedded submanifold yields on the boundary an interesting structure. For that, let and take as in the beginning of section 2.
We are now ready to introduce the main result of this section. Before that, we introduce an appropriate definition which fits with the type of fibration structure we are able to prove on the boundary of the Milnor fibration.
Following H. Winkelnkemper in [42], A. Ranicki [39]111including the appendix ”The history and applications of open books”, by H. E. Winkelnkemper, E. Looijenga [18], see also [15] and [4, section 3], given a smooth manifold and a submanifold of codimension in suppose that for some trivialization of a tubular neighbourhood of in the fiber bundle defined by the composition in the diagram below
where extends to a smooth locally trivial fiber bundle e.i.,
In such a case the pair above will be called a generalized -open-book decomposition on with binding and page the fiber
The main result of this section is:
Theorem 3.2.
Let be a tame map germ with Then, for each such that the pair is a generalized -open-book decomposition, with binding and page - the interior of the Milnor fiber
Proof.
Consider the restriction map It follows by Lemma 3.1 that we may adjust the radii of the fibrations (3), (4) and (5) such that for a small enough radius in the diagram below
(13) |
the projection is a (trivial) locally fiber bundle, where is the radial projection.
It induces the trivial fibration on the diagonal projection
(14) |
Applying again the Lemma 3.1 in the diagram below we get that the horizontal map is a locally trivial fibration over its image; and thus, the diagonal projection is again a locally trivial smooth fibration.
(15) |
Now we may glue the fibrations (13) and (15) along the fibration (14) to get a smooth projection of a locally trivial fiber bundle
(16) |
Now see that the diffeomorphism of (11) says that the trivialization in the horizontal map of the diagram (9) is given by
Hence the fiber of the diagonal fibration in the diagram (13) should be diffeomorphiuc to

On the other hand, the diffeomorphism (12) assures that the fiber in the diagonal projection of the diagram (15) should be diffeomorphic to The fiber of the boundary trivial fibration (14) is clearly diffeomorphic to Therefore, we conclude that the fiber of fibration (16) must be diffeomorphic to the gluing (using the identity diffeomorphism on the boundary) See Figure (3) and the proof is finished for i.e., ∎
Remark 3.3.
Notice that for , a generalized open-book decomposition is an open-book in the usual sense. We also remark that in Theorem 3.2 we assumed If we consider the case then by convention and so there is nothing to be said. For then the study of the restriction function reduces to that of Proposition 2.3 and the construction above leads to a "fibration" over
3.1. The case of ICIS holomorphic map germ
Let us consider now a holomorphic map germ For consider the complex projections and Thus, the compositions as in the diagram (1) becomes and
If we assume further that is ICIS, it is known that is a complex hypersurface in and then for all small enough the space where stand for the open ball in Then, the space is a connected space.
In fact, it was proved by H. Hamm, Lê D. Tràng and by E. Looijenga in [17] that there exists small enough such that for each there exists such that the projection map
is a smooth locally trivial fibration. Thus, by the connectedness property of the base space the Milnor fiber is uniquely defined, up to diffeomorphism.
In addition to that, the ICIS condition is equivalent to the condition Hence, is tame according to the Definition 2.1. We may also use the argument of Looijenga in [17] for a "good representative" to guarantee that, up to a linear coordinate change in it follows that either map germ and are ICIS as well.
The following result is an interesting application of our Theorem 3.2 and also it provides an extension of [7, Proposition 3.2, p. 481]. See also [33, Chapter 3] and compare with [7, Proposition 3.2, p. 481].
Proposition 3.4.
Let be a germ of ICIS such that and are ICIS as well. Then, the Milnor projection induces a generalized -open-book decomposition on the boundary with binding
Proof.
Since then and the dimension of the sphere on the target space is Hence, the same ideas in the proof of Theorem 3.2 work in this case. ∎
Remark 3.5.
- (1)
-
(2)
Still the complex ICIS above, the generalized open-book decomposition also extends with the same proof for the pair links where and for all smal enough.
4. The Euler characteristic formulae
Let be an analytic map-germ. We will assume along the section that is tame and Thus, and
Denote by the closed manifold built by gluing two copies of along the boundary using the identity diffeomorphism on By the additive property of the Euler characteristic we have that Hence
(17) |
Applying again the additive Euler characteristic to the diffeomorphism (9) we get
Thus, together with (17) it reduces to
(18) |
We may consider the convention and the fact that for the dimensional sphere Then all the above discussion, including the special cases of and may be summarized as below. By convention, for we denote
Theorem 4.1.
Let be an analytic map-germ, tame with Then:
-
for any
-
Lê-Greuel’s type formula: for any
-
for any
Proof.
The item follows from the identity (18). To prove the item just exchange by in the item and take the difference. The item is immediate from item ∎
4.1. Relating the Euler characteristic of the links
Consider again a tame polynomial map-germ with For each the map admits the Milnor tube fibrations (4) and by restriction it induces the fibrations with Milnor fibers and the fibration with fiber
Denote by the Milnor tube of and by the respective link.
We may consider small enough such that the sphere is homeomorphic to the gluing where is a semi-algebraic neighbourhood that retract to the link as proved by A. Durfee in [13].
Thus,
Hence,
(19) |
Lemma 4.2.
The following holds true:
The next result provides in particular a second proof of [14, Proposition 7.1, p. 4861].
Proposition 4.3.
Let be a tame polynomial map-germ with Then:
-
for each
-
for each
Proof.
In the equation (19) just exchange by and take the difference. Then we have
Now we may apply Proposition 4.1, item to get
This ends the proof of item Item is trivial. ∎
Remark 4.4.
Definition 4.5.
Let be a tame polynomial map-germ with . The degree of degeneracy on the Milnor boundary of is defined as the number
Clearly, if has an isolated singularity at the origin one has that .
5. On the boundaries of the Milnor fibers and the links on each stage I.
In the real setting we do not expect to prove theorems regarding the degree of connectivity of the Milnor fibers, its boundaries nor the respective links of on each stage . Notwithstanding, in the case where the dimension of the source space is even, for all we may write and as an application of Lemma 4.2 we conclude that and hence However, if the source space is odd-dimensional some interesting relations between the boundaries of the Milnor fiber, the links of the singularities and the Milnor fibers on the Milnor tubes come up on each stage , and it provides a way to distinguish between the homotopy type of the Milnor boundary and the link of the singularities for each as described below.
We first remind that for odd dimension the equation (19) becomes
This allows us to prove the below result whose proof we left as an exercise.
Lemma 5.1.
Let odd and such that Then, for each the following conditions hold for the links and the boundaries of the Milnor fibers
-
(1)
if is even then by equation Moreover, since is odd then
-
(2)
if is odd then by equation Moreover, since is odd then
Now we are ready to state the main result of this section.
Theorem 5.2.
Consider odd, Let and be real analytic map germs as in the diagram (1). Then, if and only if in some stage Moreover, if the last equality holds true on any stage it also will holds true on all stages
Proof.
The proof follows from Lemma 5.1.
For the "if" case, we can see that implies that the two quantities in the either cases of Lemma 5.1. Moreover, the equality in some stage clearly implies that on all
For the "only if" case, if we suppose that in some stage (even or odd) the equality holds true, then again by Lemma 5.1 we conclude that Therefore, ∎
The next result provides a natural class of map germs where one of two conditions above holds true. Beside that, it also provides another proof of [3, Proposition 3, item ii), p. 71].
Corollary 5.3.
Let , with and odd, be a real analytic map-germ with an isolated critical point at the origin. Then, for each we have that
Proof.
The proof might be left as exercise, but we will screatch it below for the sake of convenience.
Since have an isolated singular point at the origin, one may apply the diagram (2) to get that for each fixed It is enough to consider the case because the case the result follows as an easy application of the Inverse Function Theorem version for map germs.
Now, if we assume further that is odd then for each the link must be not empty, and it is in fact a smooth manifold diffeomorphic to and thus Therefore, one may apply the Theorem 5.2 and conclude that for each ∎
Remark 5.4.
For the existence of map germ M odd, with isolated critical point at the origin, the reader may consult [4, section 5.2, p. 101].
Corollary 5.5.
Let and be as in Theorem 5.2. If then at all stages the Milnor boundary and the respective link of cannot be homotopically equivalent.
Proof.
It is now trivial because on each stage Therefore, by Theorem 5.2 the respectives Milnor boundary and the link can not be homotopically equivalent. ∎
The next example shows that for odd-dimension it is easy to construct a family of map germ where the Euler characteristic of the Milnor fiber is not equal to one.
Example 5.6.
Let be an analytic map germ with and be an analytic ramified covering map branched along with t-sheets, Then, for all fixed and all the map is a local diffeomorphism and the fiber consists of a finite number of points, and we set Thus, and the composition map germ safisfies that Since is tame, it is not hard to see that is tame as well. Then the map admits a Milnor tube fibration with Milnor fiber (t-disjoint copies of ). Therefore we have that where we use that by Corollary 5.3.
References
- [1] M. Aguilar, A. Menegon, J. Seade. On the boundary of the Milnor fiber. In “Singularities and Their Interaction with Geometry and Low Dimensional Topology", in honor of A. Némethi. J. Fernández de Bobadilla, T. Laszlo and A. Stipsicz (Eds.), Birkhauser. ISBN 978-3-030-61957-2.
- [2] R. N. Araújo dos Santos, Y. Chen, M. Tibăr, Singular open book structures from real mappings. Cent. Eur. J. Math. 11 (2013) no. 5, 817-828.
- [3] R. N. Araújo dos Santos, D. Dreibelbis, N. Dutertre, Topology of the real Milnor fiber for isolated singularities. In Real and Complex Singularities, Contemporary Mathematics Vol. 569 (Amer. math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2012).
- [4] R. N. Araújo dos Santos, M. Hohlenwerger, O. Saeki, T. Souza. New examples of Neuwirth-Stallings pairs and non-trivial real Milnor fibrations. Annales de l’Institut Fourier, Volume 66 (2016) no. 1, pp. 83–104. doi : 10.5802/aif.3006. https://aif.centre-mersenne.org/articles/10.5802/aif.3006/
- [5] R. N. Araújo dos Santos, M. F. Ribeiro, Geometrical Conditions for the Existence of a Milnor Vector Field. Bulletin Brazilian Mathematical Society (online), v. 52, p. 771-789, 2020.
- [6] R. N. Araújo dos Santos, M.F. Ribeiro, M. Tibăr, Fibrations of highly singular map germs. Bull. Sci. Math. 155 (2019), 92-111. Online https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bulsci.2019.05.001
- [7] C. Caubel. Contact structures and non-isolated singularities. In Singularity theory. Dedicated to Jean-Paul Brasselet on his 60-th birthday. D. Chéniot et al. eds., 475-485. World Scientific, Hackensach, N.J., 2007. https://doi.org/10.1142/9789812707499_0018
- [8] Y. Chen, Milnor fibration at infinity for mixed polynomials. Cent. Eur. J. Math. 12, (2014) 28-38.
- [9] P.T. Church and K. Lamotke, Non-trivial polynomial isolated singularities, Nederl. Akad. Wetensch. Proc. Ser. A 78 = Indag. Math. 37 (1975), 149-154.
- [10] J-L. Cisneros-Molina, A. Menegon, Equivalence of Milnor and Milnor-Lê fibrations for real analytic maps. Int. J. Math., vol. 30, n. 14, 1950078 (2019).
- [11] J-L. Cisneros-Molina, J. Seade, and N. G. Grulha Jr. On the topology of real analytic maps, International Journal of Mathematics, Vol. 25, No. 07, 1450069- (2014). https://doi.org/10.1142/S0129167X14500694
- [12] J-L. Cisneros-Molina, J. Seade, J. Snoussi, Refinements of Milnor’s fibration theorem for complex singularities. Advances in Mathematics, 222, 2009, 937–970. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aim.2009.05.010
- [13] A. H. Durfee, Neighborhoods of algebraic sets, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 276 (1983), no. 2, 517–530.
- [14] N. Dutertre, R. N. Araújo dos Santos, Topology of Real Milnor Fibrations for Non-Isolated Singularities, International Mathematics Research Notices, Volume 2016, Issue 16, 2016, Pages 4849–4866, https://doi.org/10.1093/imrn/rnv286
- [15] N. Dutertre, R. N. Araújo dos Santos, Y. Chen, A. A. E. Santo. Open book structures on semi-algebraic manifolds. Manuscripta Math. 149, 205–222 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00229-015-0772-4
- [16] J. Fernández de Bobadilla and A. Menegon. The boundary of the Milnor fiber of complex and real analytic non-isolated singularities, Geom. Dedicata 173 (2014) 143-162.
- [17] E. Looijenga. Isolated Singular Points on Complete Intersections. London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series (1984). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511662720
- [18] E. Looijenga. A note on polynomial isolated singularities. Indagationes Mathematicae (Proceedings) Volume 74, 1971, Pages 418-421. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1385-7258(71)80049-5
- [19] D. T. Lê, Some remarks on relative monodromy. Real and complex singularities (Proc. Ninth Nordic Summer School/NAVF Sympos. Math., Oslo, 1976), pp. 397-403. Sijthoff and Noordhoff, Alphen aan den Rijn, 1977.
- [20] S. López de Medrano. Singularities of homogeneous quadratic mappings. Rev. R. Acad. Cienc. Exactas Física. Nat. Ser. A Math. RACSAM, 108(1): 95–112, 2014.
- [21] S. López de Medrano, Topology and Geometry of Intersections of Ellipsoids in , Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, Springer Cham, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-28364-2
- [22] D. B. Massey, Real analytic Milnor fibrations and a strong Łojasiewicz inequality. Real and Complex Singularities, 268-292, London Math. Soc. Lecture Note Ser., 380, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 2010.
- [23] A. Menegon, Thom property and Milnor-Lê fibration for analytic maps. Math. Nachrichten, 2023.
- [24] A. Menegon, J-L., Cisneros et al., Fibration Theorems a la Milnor for analytic maps with non-isolated singularities, Preprint.
- [25] A. Menegon and C. S. Marques-Silva On the topology of the Milnor-Lê fibration for functions of three real variables. Bull. of the Brazilian Math. Soc. 53 (2022), 461–477.
- [26] A. Menegon and R. S. Martins Milnor-Lê type fibrations for subanalytic maps. Bol. Soc. Mat. Mexicana, (2022)28:30.
- [27] A. Menegon and J. Seade, On the Lê-Milnor fibration for real analytic maps. Mathematische Nachrichten, vol. 290, p. 382-392 (2017).
- [28] A. Menegon and J. Seade, Vanishing zones and the topology of non-isolated singularities. Geo. Dedicata, vol. 202, p. 321-335 (2019).
- [29] F. Michel, A. Pichon. On the boundary of the Milnor fiber of non-isolated singularities, Int. Math. Res. Not. 43 (2003), 2305-2311. Erratum (2004), 309-310
- [30] F. Michel, A. Pichon. Carrousel in family and non-isolated hypersurface singularities in , J. Reine Angew. Math. (Crelle’s Journal) 720 (2016), p. 1-32.
- [31] F. Michel, A. Pichon, C. Weber. The boundary of the Milnor fiber for some non-isolated singularities of complex surfaces, Osaka J. Math. 46 (2009), 291-316.
- [32] J. Milnor, Singular points of complex hypersurfaces. Ann. of Math. Studies, Vol. 61, Princeton University Press, 1968.
- [33] A. Némethi, Á. Szilárd. Milnor fiber boundary of a non-isolated surface singularity, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 2037. Springer Verlag 2012.
- [34] M. Oka, Topology of polar weighted homogeneous hypersurface. Kodai Math. J. 31 (2008), no. 2, 163–182.
- [35] P. Popescu-Pampu. Complex singularities and contact topology. Winter Braids Lecture Notes Vol. 3 (2016), 1-74 Course no III. (https://proceedings.centre-mersenne.org/item/10.5802/wbln.14.pdf)
- [36] M. F. Ribeiro, New classes of mixed functions without Thom regularity. Bulletin of the Brazilian Mathametical Society, New Series (154) v. 50, p. 1-16, (2019). Online https://doi.org/10.1007/s00574-019-00154-z
- [37] M. F. Ribeiro, F. Reis, A. Santo, Milnor-Hamm Fibration for Mixed Maps. Bulletin Brazilian Mathematical Society (online), v. 52, p. 739-766, 2020.
- [38] M. F. Ribeiro, R. N. Araújo dos Santos, D. Dreibelbis, M. Griffin, Harmonic morphisms and their Milnor fibrations. Annali di Matematica (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10231-023-01311-4
- [39] A. Ranicki. High-dimensional Knot Theory - Algebraic Surgery in Codimension 2. Serier title: Springer Monographs in Mathematics. Springer Verlag Monographs in Mathematics,1998. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-662-12011-8
- [40] D. Siersma, Variation mappings on singularities with a 1-dimensional critical locus. Topology 30, 445-469 (1991).
- [41] D. Siersma, The vanishing topology of non isolated singularities. In "New developments in singularity theory, Cambridge 2000", p. 447-472, Kluwer, Dordrecht (2001).
- [42] H. E. Winkelnkemper. Manifolds as open books. Bull. A.M.S., 79:45–51, 1973.