Kuznetsov’s Fano threefold conjecture via Hochschild-Serre algebra
Abstract.
Let be a smooth quartic double solid regarded as a degree 4 hypersurface of the weighted projective space . We study the multiplication of the Hochschild-Serre algebra of its Kuznetsov component via matrix factorization. As an application, we give a new disproof of Kuznetsov’s Fano threefold conjecture.
Key words and phrases:
Derived categories, Kuznetsov components, Fano threefolds, matrix factorization, Hochschild cohomology, Jacobian ring.2010 Mathematics Subject Classification:
Primary 14F05; secondary 14J45, 14D20, 14D231. Introduction
Let be Fano variety whose semi-orthogonal decomposition for bounded derived category is given by
where is an exceptional collection of vector bundles over and is the right orthogonal complement of the collection, called Kuznetsov component. It has been widely believed that the Kuznetsov component encodes the essential birational geometric information of the Fano varieties. Thus extracting geometric information from Kuznetsov components is an important step to understand geometry of Fano varieties. There are numerous way to extract information from Kuznetsov components, which we briefly recall as follows.
1.1. Stability conditions in Kuznetsov components and moduli space theoretical approach
One of the most interesting class of Fano varieties are smooth Fano threefolds of Picard rank one of index one and two, whose deformation classes are completely classified in [VI99]. In the paper [BLMS17], the authors construct a stability condition in for any such Fano variety . Denote by the numerical Grothendieck group and fix a numerical class and consider the Bridgeland moduli space of (semi)stable object with respect to in of numerical class . The numerical character is appropriately chosen such that the corresponding moduli space reconstructs Fano variety of rational curves on , which is used to reconstruct (birational) isomorphism class of Fano varieties(cf. [BMMS12],[PY22], [GLZ22]).
1.2. Topological K-theory of admissible subcategory and Hodge theoretical approach
Let be an admissible subcategory of bounded derived category of a smooth projective variety . The topological K-theory [Bla16] of dg categories over is an additive invariant
with Chern character map
Furthermore , and is the usual Chern character. In particular, the natural splitting from that of gives a weight one Hodge structure for topological -group . Namely, the topological Chern character induces,
Thus, we have a complex torus associated to this weight one Hodge structure. More explicitly,
In the case of is a smooth Fano threefold with being the Kuznetsov component as the orthogonal complement of an exceptional collection of vector bundles, by [JLLZ21, Lemma 3.9] as polarised abelian varieties(which was sketched in [Per22, Section 5]). Similar construction is generalized for any smooth and proper dg category and even to arbitrary dg category in [CMHL+23] and [LXZ24]. On the other hand, in the similar spirit, topological K-theory and noncommutative Hodge theory(cf. [Bla16] and [Per22]) is applied to admissible subcategory of Fano fourfolds in [BP23] and surfaces in [DJR23] to recover Mukai lattice for K3 category and primitive cohomology for surfaces respectively. As application, (birational) categorical Torelli theorem are proved for many varieties.
1.3. Hochschild-Serre algebra and algebraic approach
The Hochschild cohomology is an algebra, and Hochschild homology is a graded module over this algebra. We now define a bi-graded algebra that contains Hochschild cohomology and Hochschild homology and encodes the algebra structure of Hochschild cohomology and the module structure of Hochschild homology over Hochschild cohomology. Let be a smooth and proper dg category and be the Serre functor of . One can naturally attach a bi-graded algebra
with multiplication map
given by the composition
for . It was studied in [Orl03] and [Căl05], [Cal03] independently when is bounded derived category of coherent sheaves on a smooth projective variety , where they prove basic property of this algebra. Moreover, in [BO01], the author uses a sub-algebra of , which is isomorphic to anti-canonical ring of a smooth Fano variety to reconstruct the variety itself. Recently this algebra is revisited in [BFK23] and [LZ23] under the name Hochschild-Serre algebra for admissible subcategory of . In particular, the authors of [LZ23] establish a sub-algebra of in the case of smooth hypersurface of degree in , which recovers the Jacobian ring of if . Thus a categorical Torelli theorem is proved for those hypersurfaces.
1.4. Kuznetsov’s Fano threefold conjecture
Denote by the moduli space of smooth Fano threefold of index and degree . In [Kuz09, Conjecture 3.7], the author proposed a surprising conjecture relating the non-trivial admissible subcategories of two families of smooth Fano threefolds.
Conjecture 1.1.
There is a correspondence , such that for any pair , there is an equivalence of categories
The conjecture is proved for and in [Kuz09]. For the remaining cases, there was a lot of evidence suggesting that the conjecture might be false. Thus instead of proving this conjecture, people disproved it. To do this, the natural idea would be looking at the information(moduli spaces, Hodge theory, algebra etc.)extracting from and respectively and then show that they are different. Indeed, in [Zha20], the author adopts the moduli theoretical approach described in Section 1.1 to study particular Bridgeland moduli spaces canonically constructed from and respectively and shows that they are not isomorphic to each other. Independently, in [BP23], the authors apply the Hodge theoretical approach in Section 1.2. They look at the Mukai-Hodge lattice of two K3 categories constructed from equivariant categories of and respectively and show that the Hodge isometry does not exist. In the current paper, we adopt another perspective described in 1.3. Namely, we look at Hochschild-Serre algebra of dg-enhancement of Kuznetsov component of quartic double solid and Gushel-Mukai threefold, which are the Fano threefolds appearing in the case of Conjecture 1.1. It turns out that they are not isomorphic to each other and the proof is very simple.
1.5. Main Results
Let be a smooth quartic double solid with the geometric involution and be a smooth Gushel-Mukai threefold. Denote by the Hochschild-Serre algebra of dg-enhancement of and respectively. Note that by [APR22, Section 3]. Then, consider the multiplication
(1) |
and associated map
Then we show
Theorem 1.2.
The kernel of the map is one dimensional.
On the other hand, from [JLLZ22, Theorem 4.6], we know the map
is injective for all ordinary Gushel-Mukai threefold . In fact, the injectivity holds for special Gushel–Mukai threefolds as well, as we will show in Lemma 3.3. Then by [JLLZ22, Theorem 4.8], , which is a contradiction. Thus we have
Corollary 1.3.
For any Gushel Mukai threefold and quartic double solid , the categories and are never equivalent. In particular, the Conjecture 1.1 for fails.
1.6. Organization of the paper
In Section 2, we recall the terminology of category of graded matrix factorization with -action on of weight . Then we describe the multiplications of Hochschild-Serre algebra for the matrix factorization. In Section 3, we describe the multiplication of Hochschild-Serre algebra for Kuznetsov component of a smooth quartic double solid and prove Theorem 1.2, as a corollary, we disproof Kuznetsov’s Fano threefold conjecture.
1.7. Acknowledgement
We would like to thank Marcello Bernardara, Pieter Belmans, Will Donovan, Junwu Tu for useful conversation on related topics. We also would like to thank the referee for the careful reading and for providing detailed comments. SZ is supported by ANR project FanoHK, grant ANR-20-CE40-0023, Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft under Germany’s Excellence Strategy-EXC-20471-390685813. Part of the work was finished when XL and SZ visited the Max-Planck Institute for Mathematics, Hausdorff Institute for Mathematics and Morningside Center of Mathematics, Chinese Academy of Sciences. They are grateful for excellent working conditions and hospitality.
2. dg category of graded matrix factorizations
In this section, we recall the terminology of -category of matrix factorization. We follow the context in [BFK14]. We refer the reader to [Kel06] for the basic of categories. Denote by the localized with respect to the quasi-equivalences of categories. Let be a quadruple where is a quasi-projective variety with action, where is a reductive algebraic group, is a -equivariant line bundle and is a -invariant section of . Our main example is . The action on is given by , are integers such that . is the trivial line bundle twisted with the character . is a -invariant section of . Namely is a degree polynomial, the weight of variable is .
We have category , whose objects are a quadruple , where and are -equivariant quasi-coherent sheaves, and are morphism of -equivariant sheaves such that
The space of morphisms in are the internal Hom of -equivariant sheaves while extending the pairs of morphisms to certain -graded complexes. We point out the reference [BFK14] for interested readers. There is a category which imitates acyclic complexes in the category of complexes of sheaves. The absolute derived category is the homotopy category of quotient . Let be the dg sub-category whose components are -equivariant injective quasi-coherent sheaves. We write [] as the homotopic category of any dg category .
Lemma 2.1.
The composition induces an equivalence of homotopic categories
Let be a sub-category whose objects are quasi-isomorphic to objects with coherent components in category .
Define shifting functor
With cone construction, the homotopic category is a triangulated category which is equivalent to the category of graded matrix factorization in [Orl09] for .
Denote by
the twisting functor that maps
to
Clearly, we have equality of functors .
Let be a smooth hypersurface of degree defined by . Let
Roughly, is identified with the essential subcategory of -branes of in Physics. If a is Calabi-Yau variety, . On side, the category is identified with the category of -branes of Landau-Ginzburg model. Physically, B-branes of and model are naturally equivalent, which was proved by Orlov [Orl09] mathematically. Namely, we have equivalence
Consider the natural enhancement , and let be a subcategory that enhance . Orlov’s /LG correspondence can be lifted to be the equivalence of dg categories.
Theorem 2.2.
[BFK14, Theorem 6.13] There is an equivalence in ,
According to [BFK14], the natural functors can be reinterpreted as kernels of Fourier-Mukai transforms, and the natural transformations between these functors are morphism of kernels. We write as the kernel of functor .
Lemma 2.3.
[FK18, Theorem 1.2] The Serre functor of is .
Proof.
Next we recall a key theorem in [BFK14, Theorem 1.2]. For , we write as the conormal sheaf of fixed locus and the character of . We write as the Koszul cohomology of the Jacobian ideal of . Let , and .
Proposition 2.4.
[BFK14, Theorem 5.39] Assume has only isolated singularty at , then
We refer the reader to [BFK14] for details of computation. We describe the multiplication under the isomorphism of Theorem 2.4. To make this self contain, we introduce some notions used in the proof.
Let be a quasi-projective variety with action, is an algebraic group. Let be a closed subgroup of . We have an action of on defined by
The fppf quotient of of is a scheme , which is denoted as , see [BFK14, Lemma 2.16]. Consider morphisms
First, the pull back functor define an equivalence of equivariant quasi-coherent sheaves. Namely
is an equivalence [Tho87, Lemma 1.3]. We write as the push forward functor of , and as the pull back functor of .
Definition 2.5.
We still write and as derived functors of derived categories of equivariant sheaves. is right adjoint functor of . In our case, , , and via diagonal embedding. The action on is given by
By definition,
The multiplication
maps to is the composition
(2) |
To avoid cluttering the notation, we temporarily assume . The sequence (2) is equivalent to
Here are regarded as equivariant morphisms in via diagonal embedding . The morphism here is .
Next, let be the graph . The action on is defined by . By [BFK14, Lemma 5.31], as sheaves. Note that the decomposition of the object into a direct sum corresponds exactly to the decomposition in Proposition 2.4, which identifies different Hom-spaces with the pieces of Jacobian rings.
Let , and .
Theorem 2.6.
The multiplication map
is given by the composition of the following diagram
(3) |
Here in the left box the component morphism in is the result of the action of the group element on the morphism . In particular is multiplication of functions.
Proof.
This is essentially the duality of functors and . The element defines an isomorphism
Since is a invariant morphism, other morphisms except in the left box are uniquely determined by the invariant morphisms via diagonal embedding. After identifying with certain homogeneous degree of , is the composition of functions, hence multiplication of polynomials. ∎
Remark 2.7.
It is easy to observe that the Hochschild-Serre algebra of the graded matrix factorization is not commutative in general.
3. Kuznetsov’s Fano threefold conjecture for quartic double solids and Gushel-Mukai threefolds
Theorem 3.1.
Let be a smooth quartic double solid, whose semi-orthogonal decomposition is given by
where is the Kuznetsov component of the quartic double solid . The canonical map induced by multiplication map (1) of Hochschild-Serre algebra
has one dimensional kernel.
Proof.
We regard as a degree smooth hypersurface in weighted projective space . According to Theorem 2.2, , where is the polynomial defining , and the -action on is of weight . Then by Proposition 2.4, we have
(4) |
where .
-
•
If , then , .
-
•
If , then , .
-
•
If , then , .
-
•
If , then , .
Note that the Serre functor of the matrix factorization category is by Lemma 2.3, We write , then
(5) | ||||
(6) | ||||
(7) |
Let and , corresponding to (5) and (7) respectively. As explain in Theorem 2.6 and see also the diagram (3), we have morphisms , , ; , , ; , , ; , , . According to Theorem 2.6, the composition
is represented by
Namely, the composition is
Consider element and . Then,
where the composition lies in by , thus .
By [Don83, Theorem 2.6] the map
is a non-degeneration multiplication. Thus the map
is injective. On the other hand, simple computation shows , , and . Then the map
is also injective.
Hence the canonical map
has one dimensional kernel. ∎
Lemma 3.2.
Proof.
Lemma 3.3.
Let be a special Gushel-Mukai threefold, then the morphism
is injective.
Proof.
By [KP18, Lemma 3.8] and [KP19, Theorem 1.6], for any special Gushel-Mukai threefold , there is an ordinary Gushel-Mukai threefold such that is a Fourier-Mukai type equivalence. Then by [JLLZ22, Theorem 4.8], injectivity of is equivalent to injectivity of . By Lemma 3.2, is injective. Thus is injective. ∎
Corollary 3.4.
For any Gushel-Mukai threefold and quartic double solid , there is no Fourier-Mukai type equivalence between the category and .
Proof.
Assume there is a Fourier-Mukai type equivalence for any quartic double solid and ordinary Gushel-Mukai threefold . Then [JLLZ22, Theorem 4.8] tells us the morphism is injective if and only if is injective. Then by Lemma 3.2 and Lemma 3.3, the map is injective for all smooth Gushel-Mukai threefolds. Thus is also injective, which contradicts Theorem 3.1. ∎
Remark 3.5.
In this paper, we work with dg-enhanced Kuznetsov categories, so any equivalence between them amounts to a Fourier-Mukai type equivalence. But in the cases of interest in this paper, all the equivalences between triangulated categories and are proved to be of Fourier-Mukai type in [LPZ22], so there is no harm to work with enhanced Kuznetsov components.
References
- [APR22] Matteo Altavilla, Marin Petkovic, and Franco Rota. Moduli spaces on the kuznetsov component of fano threefolds of index 2. Épijournal de Géométrie Algébrique, 6, 2022.
- [BFK14] Matthew Ballard, David Favero, and Ludmil Katzarkov. A category of kernels for equivariant factorizations and its implications for hodge theory. Publ.math.IHES, 120(1-111), 2014.
- [BFK23] Pieter Belmans, Lie Fu, and Andreas Krug. Hochschild cohomology of hilbert schemes of points on surfaces. arXiv preprint arXiv:2309.06244, 2023.
- [Bla16] Anthony Blanc. Topological k-theory of complex noncommutative spaces. Compositio Mathematica, 152(3):489–555, 2016.
- [BLMS17] Arend Bayer, Martí Lahoz, Emanuele Macrì, and Paolo Stellari. Stability conditions on Kuznetsov components. (Appendix joint with Xiaolei Zhao) To appear in Ann. Sci. Éc. Norm. Supér., arXiv:1703.10839, 2017.
- [BMMS12] Marcello Bernardara, Emanuele Macrì, Sukhendu Mehrotra, and Paolo Stellari. A categorical invariant for cubic threefolds. Advances in Mathematics, 229(2):770–803, 2012.
- [BO01] Alexei Bondal and Dmitri Orlov. Reconstruction of a variety from the derived category and groups of autoequivalences. Compositio Mathematica, 125(3):327–344, 2001.
- [BP23] A. Bayer and A. Perry. Kuznetsov’s Fano threefold conjecture via K3 categories and enhanced group actions. J. Reine Angew. Math., 800:107–153, 2023.
- [Cal03] Andrei Caldararu. The mukai pairing, i: the hochschild structure. arXiv preprint math/0308079, 2003.
- [Căl05] Andrei Căldăraru. Derived categories of sheaves: a skimming. Snowbird lectures in algebraic geometry, 388:43–75, 2005.
- [CMHL+23] Sebastian Casalaina-Martin, Xianyu Hu, Lin.Xun, Shizhuo Zhang, and Zheng Zhang. Categorical torelli theorem via equivariant kuznetsov component of cubic threefolds. preprint, 2023.
- [DJR23] Hannah Dell, Augustinas Jacovskis, and Franco Rota. Cyclic covers: Hodge theory and categorical torelli theorems. arXiv preprint arXiv:2310.13651, 2023.
- [Don83] Ron. Donagi. Generic torelli for projective hypersurfaces. Compositio Mathematica, 50(2-3):323–353, 1983.
- [FK18] David Favero and Tyler Kelly. Fractional calabi–yau categories from landau–ginzburg models. Algebraic Geometry, 5(5):596–649, 2018.
- [GLZ22] Hanfei Guo, Zhiyu Liu, and Shizhuo Zhang. Conics on gushel-mukai fourfolds, epw sextics and bridgeland moduli spaces. arXiv preprint arXiv:2203.05442, 2022.
- [JLLZ21] A. Jacovskis, X. Lin, Z. Liu, and S. Zhang. Categorical Torelli theorems for Gushel-Mukai threefolds. arXiv preprint arXiv:2108.02946, 2021.
- [JLLZ22] Augustinas Jacovskis, Xun Lin, Zhiyu Liu, and Shizhuo Zhang. Infinitesimal categorical torelli theorems for fano threefolds. arXiv preprint arXiv:2203.08187, 2022.
- [Kel06] Bernhard Keller. On differential graded categories. arXiv preprint math/0601185, 2006.
- [KP18] Alexander Kuznetsov and Alexander Perry. Derived categories of gushel–mukai varieties. Compositio Mathematica, 154(7):1362–1406, 2018.
- [KP19] Alexander Kuznetsov and Alexander Perry. Categorical cones and quadratic homological projective duality. arXiv preprint arXiv:1902.09824, 2019.
- [Kuz09] Alexander Gennad’evich Kuznetsov. Derived categories of fano threefolds. Proceedings of the Steklov Institute of Mathematics, 264:110–122, 2009.
- [LPZ22] Chunyi Li, Laura Pertusi, and Xiaolei Zhao. Derived categories of hearts on kuznetsov components. arXiv preprint arXiv:2203.13864, 2022.
- [LXZ24] Xun Lin, Fei Xie, and Shizhuo Zhang. Singular category: Hodge theory and (birational) categorical torelli theorem for nodal fano threefolds. preprint, 2024.
- [LZ23] Xun Lin and Shizhuo Zhang. Serre algebra, matrix factorization and categorical torelli theorem for hypersurfaces. arXiv preprint arXiv:2310.09927, 2023.
- [Orl03] Dmitri Olegovich Orlov. Derived categories of coherent sheaves and equivalences between them. Russian Mathematical Surveys, 58(3):511, 2003.
- [Orl09] Dmitri Orlov. Derived categories of coherent sheaves and triangulated categories of singularities. Algebra, Arithmetic, and Geometry: Volume II: In Honor of Yu. I. Manin, pages 503–531, 2009.
- [Per22] Alexander Perry. The integral Hodge conjecture for two-dimensional Calabi–Yau categories. Compositio Mathematica, 158(2):287–333, 2022.
- [PY22] L. Pertusi and S. Yang. Some remarks on Fano three-folds of index two and stability conditions. Int. Math. Res. Not. IMRN, (17):12940–12983, 2022.
- [Tho87] R.W Thomason. Equivariant resolution, linearization, and hilbert’s fourteenth problem over arbitrary base schemes. Advances in Mathematics, Volume 65, Issue 1, 1987.
- [VI99] Yuri Vasilevich Prokhorov V.A. Iskovskikh. Algebraic Geometry V: Fano Varieties. Algebraic geometry. Springer, 1999.
- [Zha20] Shizhuo Zhang. Bridgeland moduli spaces and Kuznetsov’s Fano threefold conjecture. arXiv preprint 2012.12193, 2020.