Finite -algebras of and Ghost centers
Abstract.
We prove that the finite -algebra associated to and its principal nilpotent element is isomorphic to Gorelikβs ghost center of , which proves an analog of Kostantβs theorem for .
1. Introduction
A Lie suparalgebra is a finite-dimensional simple Lie superalgebra whose Dynkin diagram is the same as type except for a unique simple short root, which is replaced by a non-isotropic odd simple root in . The Lie suparalgebra is not a Lie algebra but has similar properties to simple Lie algebras. For example, the category of finite-dimensional -modules is semisimple and we have the Harish-Chandra isomorphism , where denotes the center of the universal enveloping algebra , is a Cartan subalgebra of and is the Weyl group. However doesnβt satisfy the Duflo theorem [Duf77], which says that annihilators of Verma modules in is generated by its intersections with the center for simple Lie algebras . This problem was founded by Musson [Mus97] and solved by Gorelik and Lantzmann [GL00] by using an extension algebra of . More precisely, Gorelik and Lantzmann prove that annihilators of Verma modules in is generated by its intersections with . The associative algebra is called the ghost center of in [Gor00].
For a Lie superalgebra with , the ghost center is introduced by Gorelik in [Gor00] as the direct sum , where is the anticenter defined by . If is a finite-dimensional simple basic classical Lie superalgebra, it is known that coincides with the center of and thus is a purely even subalgebra of . Moreover, if , there exists such that by [ABF97, Mus97, GL00]. The element is called the Casimir ghost [ABF97] since . In case , [Pin90] also suggested that satisfies , where is the Casimir element in and is one in .
The finite -algebra is an associative superalgebra over defined from a simple basic classical Lie superalgebra and its even nilpotent element [Pre02, Pre07, Kos78, Lyn79, dBT94, RS99, GG02]. If is a simple Lie algebra and is a principal nilpotent element , the corresponding finite -algebra is isomorphic to the center of by Kostant [Kos78].
The -algebra is a vertex superalgebra defined by the Drinfeld-Sokolov reductions associated to and level [FF92, KRW03]. In general, (Ramond-twisted) simple modules of a -graded vertex superalgebras with a Hamiltonian operator are classified by the associated superalgebra named as the (-twisted) Zhu algebras of . De Sole and Kac shows that the -twisted Zhu algebra of is isomorphic to the finite -algebra . In particular, there exists a one-to-one correspondence between simple modules of and Ramond-twisted simple positive-energy modules of . If , the corresponding -algebra is called the principal -algebra of , which we denoted by .
Theorem A (Theorem 6.5).
is isomorphic to as associative algebras.
The finite -algebra associated to and its principal nilpotent element is an associative superalgebra with its non-trivial odd part, while the ghost center is not. However, we prove an isomorphism between them. Through the isomorphism in Theorem A, a -grading of is inherited from one of so that the even part of is and the odd part is .
To prove Theorem A, we use the Miura map and its injectivity and relationship with the Harish-Chandra homomorphism of . See Section 4 for the definition of . The map was originally introduced in [Lyn79]. The injectivity of was only known for non-super cases, but has been recently proved by [Nak20] for super cases. As a corollary of Theorem A, it follows that simple positive-energy Ramond-twisted modules of principal -algebras are classified by simple modules of the ghost center of . See also Corollary 6.7. We remark that our definitions of is different from those in some literatures [Pol13, PS13, ZS15]. See Remark 4.4.
The paper is organized as follows. In Sect.2, we introduce -twisted Zhu algebras. In Sect.3, we recall the definitions of -algebras . In Sect.4, we introduce two definitions and of finite -algebras and show the equivalence of the definitions, that is, . The proof is similar to [DDCDS+]. In Sect.5, we recall the principal -algebras of . In Sect.6, we prove Theorem A.
AcknowledgmentsβThe author wishes to thank Thomas Creutzig, Tomoyuki Arakawa, Hiroshi Yamauchi and Maria Gorelik for valuable comments and suggestions. Some part of this work was done while he was visiting Instituto de MatemΓ‘tica Pura e Aplicada, Brazil in March and April 2022 and the Centre de Recherches MathαΈΏatiques, UniversitΓ© de MontrΓ©al, Canada in October 2022. He is grateful to those institutes for their hospitality. He is supported by World Premier International Research Center Initiative (WPI), MEXT, Japan and JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number JP21K20317.
2. -twisted Zhu algebras
Let be a vertex superalgebra. Denote by the vacuum vector, by the translation operator, by the parity of and by the field on corresponding to . Let
be the -bracket of and for . A Hamiltonian operator on is a semisimple operator on satisfying that for all . The eigenvalue of is called the conformal weight. If is conformal and is the field corresponding to the conformal vector of , we may choose as the Hamiltonian operator.
Suppose that is a -graded vertex superalgebra with respect to a Hamiltonian operator . Denote by the conformal weight of . Define the -product and -product of by
Then the quotient space
has a structure of associative superalgebra with respect to the product induced from , and is called the -twisted Zhu algebra of . Here . The vacuum vector defines a unit of . A superspace is called a Ramond-twisted -module if is equipped with a parity-preserving linear map
such that (1) for each , if , (2) and (3) for any , , , and ,
Hence the Ramond-twisted module is a twisted module of for the automorphism . In particular, is just a -module if is -graded. Define by for . A Ramond-twisted -module is called positive-energy if has an -grading with such that for all , and . Then is called the top space. By [DSK06, Lemma 2.22], a linear map induces a homomorphism . Thus we have a functor from the category of positive-energy Ramond-twisted -modules to the category of -graded -modules. By [DSK06, Theorem 2.30], these functors establish a bijection (up to isomorphisms) between simple positive-energy Ramond-twisted -modules and simple -graded -modules.
3. -algebras
Let be a finite-dimensional simple Lie superalgebra with the normalized even supersymmetric invariant bilinear form and be a nilpotent element in the even part of . Then there exists a -grading on that is good for . See [KRW03] for the definitions of good gradings and [EK05, Hoy12] for the classifications. Let be the homogeneous subspace of with degree . The good grading for on satisfies the following properties:
-
(1)
,
-
(2)
,
-
(3)
is injective for and surjective for ,
-
(4)
if ,
-
(5)
, where is the centralizer of in .
Then we can choose a set of simple roots of for a Cartan subalgebra such that all positive root vectors lie in . Denote by and for . We have . Let be a linear map defined by . Since is an isomorphism of vector spaces, the super skew-symmetric bilinear form is non-degenerate. We fix a root vector and denote by the parity of for .
Let be the affine vertex superalgebra associated to at level , which is generated by () whose parity is the same as , satisfying that
Let be the neutral vertex superalgebra associated to , which is strongly generated by () whose parity is equal to , satisfying that
Let be the charged fermion vertex superalgebra associated to , which is strongly generated by () whose parities are equal to , satisfying that
Let and be an odd element in defined by
Then defines a cochain complex with respect to the charged degree: () and for all . The (affine) -algebra associated to , at level is defined by
Let be a subcomplex generated by (), () and
Then we have [KW04]
Thus, is a vertex subalgebra of . Using the fact that
where denotes the Killing form on , it follows that the vertex algebra generated by is isomorphic to the affine vertex superalgebra associated to and , which we denote by . Therefore the homogeneous subspace of with charged degree is isomorphic to . The projection induces a vertex superalgebra surjective homomorphism so that we have
by the restriction. The map is called the Miura map and injective thanks to [Fre05, Ara17, Nak20].
4. Finite -algebras
Recall the definitions of finite -algebras , following [DDCDS+]. We introduce two definitions in (4.1), (4.2) denoted by , respectively and prove the isomorphism in Theorem 4.2.
Let be an associative -superalgebra generated by that has the same parity as , satisfying that
Here denotes . We extend the definition of for all by for . Let be the Clifford superalgebra associated to , which is an associative -superalgebra generated by with the opposite parity to that of , satisfying that
The Clifford superalgebra has the charged degree defined by for all . Set
where is the structure constant defined by . Then a pair forms a cochain complex with respect to the charged degree on and the cohomology
(4.1) |
has a structure of an associative -superalgebra inherited from that of . Let
Then
Let be the subalgebra of generated by , and be the subalgebra of generated by , and . Then form subcomplexes and as vector superspaces. Since , we have
Using the same argument as in [KW04], it follows that for . Therefore is a subalgebra of , which is generated by and . Since for , there exists an isomorphism as associative -superalgebras. The projection induces an associative -superalgebra surjective homomorphism so that we have
by the restriction. The map is called the Miura map for the finite -algebras and injective by [Lyn79, Gen20, Nak20]. Let be the one-dimensional -module defined by and be the induced left -module
where is a left -module generated by for all . Then has a structure of the -module inherited from that of . Set the -invariant subspace
(4.2) |
Then also has a structure of an associative -superalgebra inherited from that of . We may also define as the Chevalley cohomology of the left -module :
Theorem 4.2 ([DDCDS+, Theorem A.6]).
There exists an isomorphism as associative -superalgebras.
Proof.
Though the assertion is proved in [DDCDS+] for Lie algebras , the same proof applies as follows. Let be the Chevalley cohomology complex of the left -module , where is the subalgebra of generated by for all , and be the derivation of the cochain complex . Let be a left -module defined by the diagonal action, where is considered as a left -module by the left multiplication, and be the induced left -module
Let be the one-dimensional -module defined by and be a right -module defined by the diagonal action, where is considered as a right -module by the right multiplication. Then we have
so that is a left - right -bimodule. Note that there is an isomorphisms of vector superspaces, where is the subalgebra of generated by for all . Let be the derivation of the Chevalley homology complex of the right -module . Then is clearly a left -module with respect to the adjoint -action. Now, let be the derivation of the Chevalley cohomology complex of the left -module . Then, as in [DDCDS+], we get a new cochain complex defined by
where denotes the parity of the part of elements in . Then it is easy to check that the following linear map
with , is well-defined and induces an isomorphism of complexes since . Now
Thus, since and commute, we have
The above argument together with the isomorphism of complexes shows that and are quasi-isomorphic via the following quasi-isomorphism
(4.3) |
which preserves the associative superalgebra structures on the cohomologies. β
Definition 4.3.
The finite -algebra associated to is defined to be the superalgebra , which is isomorphic to due to Theorem 4.2.
Remark 4.4.
The same results as Theorem 4.2 for Poisson superalgebra versions has been studied in [Suh16]. Also remark that our definitions of the finite -algebra are not necessarily equivalent to the definitions in some literatures [Pol13, PS13, ZS15]. In fact, in case that and its principal nilpotent element, we have and thus . Then is a proper subalgebra of .
The vertex superalgebra has a conformal vector if , which defines the conformal weights on by , where . See [KRW03] for the details. Then defines a Hamiltonian operator on , the vertex subalgebra and the corresponding -algebra . Moreover the Hamiltonian operator is well-defined for all . Recall that is the -twisted Zhu algebra of , see Section 2. Let such that for . Then by [Ara17, DSK06],
(4.4) |
for , and so that
(4.5) |
Let be any -graded vertex superalgebras with the Hamiltonian operators and any vertex superalgebra homomorphism preserving the conformal weights. Since , the map induces an algebra homomorphism
Apply for . Then we get
by construction.
5. Principal -algebras of
Consider the case that
where denotes the transpose of . Let be the standard basis of with the index set and . Then is a Cartan subalgebra of . Define by . Then forms a set of positive roots with simple roots , and , and are the (non-isotropic) odd roots in . Set and for . We may identify with through defined by for , which induces a non-degenerate bilinear form on by so that . Then corresponds to by . We have
Note that the dual Coxeter number of is equal to . Let
be a principal nilpotent element in the even part of , where denotes some root vector for . Then there exists a unique good grading on such that and . Thus
Let
be the principal -algebra of at level . The Miura map for is
where is the Heisenberg vertex algebra generated by even fields satisfying that
and is the free fermion vertex superalgebra generated by an odd field satisfying that
By [Gen17, Theorem 6.4], is strongly generated by for odd and even elements of conformal weights and such that
(5.1) |
and
(5.2) |
for some , where
which satisfy that
If ,
is a unique conformal vector of with the central charge
6. Zhu algebras of
By (4.5), we have an isomorphism
Then is induced by (4.4):
where
Let and set an isomorphism
Then we have a commutative diagram of Miura maps
By [DSK06], has a PBW basis generated by . By abuse of notation, we shall use the same notations for the generators of corresponding to by .
Lemma 6.1.
.
Proof.
We have
Thus
Therefore the assertion follows from the fact that . β
For a basic classical Lie superalgebra such that , denote by
called the center, the anticenter and the ghost center of , respectively due to [Gor00]. Then the ghost center coincides with the center of by [Gor00, Corollary 4.4.4]. In case that , there exists [ABF97, Mus97, GL00] such that
where
is the projection induced by the decomposition and is an isomorphism defined by
The element is called the Casimir ghost [ABF97] since such that , and is studied for general in [Gor00]. It is well-known [Kac84, Gor04] that the restriction of to is injective and maps onto , where is the Weyl group of , called the Harish-Chandra homomorphism of . Recall that
where is a left -module generated by for all . Define the projections by
and a linear map by
Then, using the quasi-isomorphism in (4.3), the Miura map can be identified with the restriction of the composition map to since .
Lemma 6.2.
is the element of corresponding to .
Proof.
First of all, we show that . It is enough to show that for all . Let . Since for , we have
Next, for , since , we also have
Finally, in case that ,
Therefore, belongs to . Now and by definition,
By Lemma 6.1, . Since is injective, we have . β
Theorem 6.3.
.
Proof.
Since has a PBW basis generated by , , and is a unique odd generator, has a PBW basis generated by , . Now is superalgebra generated by with the relation . Thus maps to . By (5.1), for are algebraically independent in with degree (but not necessary homogeneous). Now, by definition, on . Hence is injective. In particular, is injective. Clearly, is -invariant. Thus, contains through . Moreover
Since is a symmetric algebra of , must contain all for . Therefore
This completes the proof. β
Theorem 6.5.
The map is an isomorphisms of associative algebras.
Proof.
By definition and Lemma 6.2, for all . Thus, is injective. In particular, is injective. Using the fact that has a PBW basis generated by , , and Theorem 6.3, it follows that is a linear isomorphism. Now, we may suppose that . Then so that . Therefore defines an isomorphisms of associative algebras. This completes the proof. β
Let be the simple highest weight -module with the highest weight . Then there exists such that acts on on for all . The map is called a central character of and is induced by and one-dimensional -module defined by . Using the Harish-Chandra homomorphism, it follows that if and only if for some . Let
Denote by if . Since for all , we have for any so that is well-defined.
From now on, we will identify with by Theorem 6.5. Then is a superalgebra such that . Let be a finite-dimensional -graded simple -module. Then acts on as for some . For a non-zero parity-homogeneous element , has an opposite parity to such that . Recall that the set is identified with by . Then, using the fact that , it follows that
Hence if and only if . Since is simple, if and if , which we denote by . Here we identify with the parity change of if . Therefore we obtain the following results:
Proposition 6.6.
A finite-dimensional -graded simple -module is isomorphic to for some . In particular, there exists one-to-one correspondence between isomorphism classes (up to the parity change) of finite-dimensional -graded simple -modules and central characters of .
Corollary 6.7.
There exists a bijective correspondence between central characters of and isomorphism classes (up to the parity change) of simple positive-energy Ramond-twisted -modules with finite-dimensional top spaces.
References
- [ABF97] D.Β Arnaudon, M.Β Bauer, and L.Β Frappat. On Casimirβs ghost. Comm. Math. Phys., 187(2):429β439, 1997.
- [Ara17] Tomoyuki Arakawa. Introduction to W-algebras and their representation theory. In Perspectives in Lie theory, volumeΒ 19 of Springer INdAM Ser., pages 179β250. Springer, Cham, 2017.
- [dBT94] Jan deΒ Boer and Tjark Tjin. The relation between quantum algebras and Lie algebras. Comm. Math. Phys., 160(2):317β332, 1994.
- [DDCDS+] Alessandro DβAndrea, Corrado DeΒ Concini, Alberto DeΒ Sole, Reimundo Heluani, and VictorΒ G. Kac. Three equivalent definitions of finite -algebras. appendix to [DSK06].
- [DSK06] Alberto DeΒ Sole and VictorΒ G. Kac. Finite vs affine -algebras. Jpn. J. Math., 1(1):137β261, 2006.
- [Duf77] Michel Duflo. Sur la classification des idΓ©aux primitifs dans lβalgΓ¨bre enveloppante dβune algΓ¨bre de Lie semi-simple. Ann. of Math. (2), 105(1):107β120, 1977.
- [EK05] A.Β G. Elashvili and V.Β G. Kac. Classification of good gradings of simple Lie algebras. In Lie groups and invariant theory, volume 213 of Amer. Math. Soc. Transl. Ser. 2, pages 85β104. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2005.
- [FF92] Boris Feigin and Edward Frenkel. Affine Kac-Moody algebras at the critical level and GelΒ΄fand-DikiΔ algebras. In Infinite analysis, Part A, B (Kyoto, 1991), volumeΒ 16 of Adv. Ser. Math. Phys., pages 197β215. World Sci. Publ., River Edge, NJ, 1992.
- [Fre05] Edward Frenkel. Wakimoto modules, opers and the center at the critical level. Adv. Math., 195(2):297β404, 2005.
- [Gen17] Naoki Genra. Screening operators for -algebras. Selecta Math. (N.S.), 23(3):2157β2202, 2017.
- [Gen20] Naoki Genra. Screening operators and parabolic inductions for affine -algebras. Adv. Math., 369:107179, 62, 2020.
- [GG02] WeeΒ Liang Gan and Victor Ginzburg. Quantization of Slodowy slices. Int. Math. Res. Not., (5):243β255, 2002.
- [GL99] Maria Gorelik and Emmanuel Lanzmann. The annihilation theorem for the completely reducible Lie superalgebras. Invent. Math., 137(3):651β680, 1999.
- [GL00] Maria Gorelik and Emmanuel Lanzmann. The minimal primitive spectrum of the enveloping algebra of the Lie superalgebra . Adv. Math., 154(2):333β366, 2000.
- [Gor00] Maria Gorelik. On the ghost centre of Lie superalgebras. Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble), 50(6):1745β1764 (2001), 2000.
- [Gor04] Maria Gorelik. The Kac construction of the centre of for Lie superalgebras. J. Nonlinear Math. Phys., 11(3):325β349, 2004.
- [Hoy12] Crystal Hoyt. Good gradings of basic Lie superalgebras. Israel J. Math., 192(1):251β280, 2012.
- [Kac84] VictorΒ G. Kac. Laplace operators of infinite-dimensional Lie algebras and theta functions. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 81(2, , Phys. Sci.):645β647, 1984.
- [Kos78] Bertram Kostant. On Whittaker vectors and representation theory. Invent. Math., 48(2):101β184, 1978.
- [KRW03] VictorΒ G. Kac, Shi-Shyr Roan, and Minoru Wakimoto. Quantum reduction for affine superalgebras. Comm. Math. Phys., 241(2-3):307β342, 2003.
- [KW04] VictorΒ G. Kac and Minoru Wakimoto. Quantum reduction and representation theory of superconformal algebras. Adv. Math., 185(2):400β458, 2004.
- [Lyn79] ThomasΒ Emile Lynch. GENERALIZED WHITTAKER VECTORS AND REPRESENTATION THEORY. ProQuest LLC, Ann Arbor, MI, 1979. Thesis (Ph.D.)βMassachusetts Institute of Technology.
- [Mus97] IanΒ M. Musson. On the center of the enveloping algebra of a classical simple Lie superalgebra. J. Algebra, 193(1):75β101, 1997.
- [Nak20] Shigenori Nakatsuka. On miura maps for -superalgebras, 2020, 2005.10472.
- [Pin90] Georges Pinczon. The enveloping algebra of the Lie superalgebra . J. Algebra, 132(1):219β242, 1990.
- [Pol13] Elena Poletaeva. On finite -algebras for Lie algebras and superalgebras. SΓ£o Paulo J. Math. Sci., 7(1):1β32, 2013.
- [Pre02] Alexander Premet. Special transverse slices and their enveloping algebras. Adv. Math., 170(1):1β55, 2002. With an appendix by Serge Skryabin.
- [Pre07] Alexander Premet. Enveloping algebras of Slodowy slices and the Joseph ideal. J. Eur. Math. Soc. (JEMS), 9(3):487β543, 2007.
- [PS13] Elena Poletaeva and Vera Serganova. On finite -algebras for Lie superalgebras in the regular case. In Lie theory and its applications in physics, volumeΒ 36 of Springer Proc. Math. Stat., pages 487β497. Springer, Tokyo, 2013.
- [RS99] E.Β Ragoucy and P.Β Sorba. Yangian realisations from finite -algebras. Comm. Math. Phys., 203(3):551β572, 1999.
- [Suh16] UhiΒ Rinn Suh. Classical affine W-algebras associated to Lie superalgebras. J. Math. Phys., 57(2):021703, 34, 2016.
- [ZS15] Yang Zeng and Bin Shu. Finite -superalgebras for basic Lie superalgebras. J. Algebra, 438:188β234, 2015.