Existence and uniqueness theorems for functional equations
Abstract
In this paper we give simple extension and uniqueness theorems for restricted additive and logarithmic functional equations.
keywords:
interval, ordered dense group, ordered field, additive function, logarithmic function, interval, restricted functional equation, extensionThis article is dedicated to the memory of János Aczél (1924-2020). \msc39B52 \VOLUME32 \NUMBER1 \YEAR2024 \DOIhttps://doi.org/10.46298/cm.10830 {paper}
1 Introduction
The main purpose of this article is to show that if is an Archimedean ordered dense Abelian group, is an Abelian group and is a function such that
(1) |
then there uniquely exists an additive function such that
Analogue Theorems concerning logarithmic functions are proven as well. Let be a fixed set and define the sets , , by
If the function satisfies the functional equation
(2) |
then the function is said to be additive on the set and the equation (2) is said to be restricted additive functional equation. The restricted additive functional equations have previously been studied by many researchers. In the book [AL09] Part IV. Geometry, Section Extension of Functional Equations p. 447–460 the authors cite numerous papers that investigate the cases when there exists an additive function , that is, for all such that the function extends the function , that is, for all where denotes the domain of the function . An incomplete list of such papers is given below:
-
•
In the paper [AE65] .
-
•
In the book [A66] the first appearance of the concept of quasi-extension can be found. An additive function is said to be quasi extension of the function if is additive on a set and there exist constants , such that for all ; for all and for all . For example, if the function is defined by whenever ; whenever , then it is easy to see that function is additive on the set . Although has no additive extension to exists, to identically zero function is an additive quasi extension of the function from to .
-
•
In the paper [DL67] the cases are investigated when and is an open interval of the real line containing the origin. In this paper the notations , , has appeared first.
-
•
In [Sz72] the author generalizes the above result that is an arbitrary open set, , is a function such that for all .
-
•
In [Ri76] a simple extension theorem can be found for Pexider additive functional equation where the additivity is fulfilled in a nonempty connected open set of the real line.
-
•
In the article [A83] where is a nonempty open interval of the real line and the set is defined by
The set is a hexagon, sometimes a triangle or the empty set.
-
•
In the book [K08] is a nonempty connected open set. The extension is brought back to the theory of convex functions, but in this book the author does not consider the restricted Pexider additive functional equations.
-
•
In the article [RB87] an extension theorem can be found for restricted Pexider additive functional equations where is a nonempty connected open set.
-
•
In the book [AD89] several functional equations are considered in more general abstract algebraic settings.
Below some necessary concepts and notations are collected: Let be an ordered group. The absolute value of an element is defined by
Let be an ordered group. If and where denotes the ring of integers, then we can define the element by
An ordered group is said to be Archimedean ordered, if for every two elements , there exists , such that . An ordered group is said to be dense, if
for all with . An ordered field is said to be Archimedean ordered, if the ordered group is Archimedean ordered. (We use the concept of the field including the commutativity of the operation ’’.) A homomorphism , that is, a function with
is said to be an additive function. A homomorphism , that is, a function with
is said to be a logarithmic function. In the rest of this article we use four properties of the open intervals in the appropriately ordered structure [GK02]:
-
1.
If is an ordered group, then the open intervals are translation invariant, that is,
-
2.
If is an ordered dense Abelian group, , , , such that and , then
-
3.
If is an ordered field, then the open intervals are homothety invariant, that is, if , , such that and , then
-
4.
If is an ordered field, , , , such that and , then
Property (2) can be easily deduced from property (1), although in [GK01] can be found an example of dense Abelian semigroup which has property (2) without property (1). Similarly, property (4) can be easily deduced from property (3), although in [GK01] can also be found an example for dense Abelian semigroup which has property (4) without property (3). Our paper is structured as follows: In section 2 we consider the additive and multiplicative versions of Euclid’s Theorem, which will be the key to our extension theorems for additive and logarithmic functions respectively. In section 3 we give extension theorems for additive and logarithmic functions. In section 4 we give uniqueness theorems for additive and logarithmic functions.
2 Euclid’s Theorem
Euclid’s Elements [Eu] is one of the most influential mathematical textbooks written more than two thousand years ago. In this textbook (book X, proposition 3.) there is an algorithm using the so-called Euclidean or remainder division to give the greatest common measure of two given commensurable magnitudes. We use the modern version of this division to give our extension theorem for restricted additive functional equations. We start with the existence and uniqueness theorem of Euclidean division.
Theorem 2.1.
If is an Archimedean ordered group, , with . Then there uniquely exists an integer and an element such that
Proof 2.2.
It is easy to see that
and the union is disjoint whence the theorem is clear.
Proposition 2.3.
If is an Archimedean ordered field, , , . Then there exists , such that .
Proof 2.4.
First, we investigate the case when . Let . Thus we have that there exists such that
and by the Bernoulli inequality [B89] we have that
From the above two inequalities we obtain, that . It is also easy to see that
thus we obtain that there exists an integer such that . The case is similar.
Now we show the multiplicative version of the Euclidean division.
Theorem 2.5.
If is an Archimedean ordered field, , such that . Then there uniquely exists an integer and an element such that
Furthermore, if , then ; and if , then .
Proof 2.6.
3 Extension Theorems for additive and logarithmic functional equations
Theorem 3.1.
Let be an Archimedean ordered dense Abelian group, be a group, and be a function such that
(3) |
then there exists an additive function which extends the function .
Proof 3.2.
Define the function by
where is an arbitrarily fixed element and the element is of the form where and such that . This form of is unique by Theorem 2.1. We show that the function is additive. For this let . By Theorem 2.1. we have that
(4) |
Then
where thus . There are two cases:
-
•
If , then
-
•
If , that is, . Then
(5) and the another hand since and thus
(6) Whence we have that
We show that
For this let . Then by Euclidean division, we obtain that there exists a number and an element such that
There are three cases:
-
•
If , then
-
•
If and , then we can apply the chain of reasoning of the first case.
-
•
If and , then
whence we have that
(7) On the other hand , thus but whence we have that
(8) Thus we obtain that
Finally we show that
For this let . Then based on the relation for the sum of the intervals we get that
thus there exist elements such that . Thus by the previous part of this proof we get
Theorem 3.3.
Let be an Archimedean ordered field, be a group, , be a function such that
(9) |
then there exists a logarithmic function which extends the function .
4 Uniqueness Theorem for additive and logarithmic functional equations
Theorem 4.1.
Let be an Archimedean ordered Abelian group and be an additive function. If there exist constants with and such that
then for all .
Proof 4.2.
By the translation invariant property of intervals, it is easy to see that for all where . Let and . Then
thus we have that for all . Let be arbitrary. By the Theorem 2.1. there exists an integer and an element such that and , whence we obtain that
which completes the proof.
Corollary 4.3.
Let be an Archimedean ordered Abelian group and , be additive functions. If there exists a nonempty open interval and a constant such that
then for all .
Theorem 4.4.
Let be an Archimedean ordered field, be a group, be a logarithmic function. If there exists a nonempty internal and a constant such that
then for all .
Proof 4.5.
By the homothety invariant property of intervals, it is easy to see that for all where . Let and , then
thus we have that for all . Let be arbitrary. By the Theorem 2.5. there exists an integer and an element such that and whence we obtain that
which completes the proof.
Corollary 4.6.
Let be an Archimedean ordered group and , be an additive functions. If there exists a nonempty open interval and a constant such that
then for all .
References
- [1] \referBookA 66 \RauthorAczél J. \RtitleLectures on Functional Equations and Their Applications, \RpublisherAcademic Press, New York-London \RvolumeMathematics in Science and Engineering, Vol. 19 \Ryear1966 \Rpages544
- [2] \referPaperA 83 \RauthorAczél J. \RtitleDiamonds are not the Cauchy extensionist’s best friend \RjournalC. R.Math. Rep. Acad. Sci. Canada \Rvolume5 \Ryear1983 \Rpages259 - 264
- [3] \referBookAD 89 \RauthorAczél J. and Dhombres J. \RtitleFunctional equations in several variables \RpublisherCambridge University Press \Ryear1989 \Rpages480
- [4] \referPaperAE 65 \RauthorAczél J. and Erdős P. \RtitleThe non-existence of a Hamel-basis and the general solution of Cauchyś functional equation for nonnegative numbers \RjournalPubl. Math. Debrecen \Rvolume12 \Ryear1965 \Rpages259 - 265
- [5] \referBookB 89 \RauthorBernoulli J. \RtitlePositiones Arithmeticae de Seriebus Infinitis \RpublisherBasel \Ryear1689
- [6] \referBookEu \RauthorEuclid of Alexandria \RtitleElements \ReditorRichard Fitzpatrick’s bilingual edition \RseriesFreely downloadable PDF, typeset in a two-column format with the original Greek beside a modern English translation; also available in print as ISBN 978-0-615-17984-1 \RyearFirst edition - 2007, Revised and corrected - 2008
- [7] \referPaperGK 01 \RauthorGlavosits T. and Karácsony Zs. \RtitleSums of intervals in ordered semigroups \RjournalAn. Şt. Univ. Ovidius Constanţa, Ser. Mat. \Rvolume29 \Ryear2021 \Rnumber2 \Rpages187 - 198
- [8] \referPaperGK 02 \RauthorGlavosits T. and Karácsony Zs. \RtitleSums and products of intervals in ordered groups and fields \RjournalActa Univ. Sap., Math. \Rvolume13 \Ryear2021 \Rnumber1 \Rpages182 - 191.
- [9] \referBookAL 09 \RauthorEdited by Graham R. L., Nesetřil J. and Butler S. \RtitleThe Mathematics of Paul Erdös I, \RpublisherSpringer \Ryear2013
- [10] \referPaperDL 67 \RauthorDaróczy Z. and Losonczi L. \RtitleÜber die Erweiterung der auf einer Punktmenge additiven Funktionenen, \RjournalPubl. Math. Debrecen \Rvolume14 \Ryear1967 \Rpages239 - 245
- [11] \referBookK 08 \RauthorKuczma M. \RtitleAn introduction to the theory of functional equations and inequalities. Cauchy’s equation and Jensen’s inequality, \RpublisherFirst edition: Uniwersytet Slaski w Katowicach \Ryear1985 \RpublisherSecond edition: Birkhäuser Basel \Ryear2009
- [12] \referPaperRB 87 \RauthorRadó F. and Baker J. A. \RtitlePexider’s equation and aggregation of allocations \RjournalAequationes Math. \Rvolume32 \Ryear1987 \Rpages227 - 239
- [13] \referPaperRi 76 \RauthorRimán J. \RtitleOn an extension of pexiders’s equation \RjournalZbornik Radova Mat. Inst. Beograd N. S., Symposium en Quasigroupes et Équations Fonctionnelles (Belgrade-Novi Sad, 1974) \Rvolume1 \Ryear1976 \Rnumber9 \Rpages65 - 72
- [14] \referPaperSz 72 \RauthorSzékelyhidi L. \RtitleThe general representation of an additive function on an open point set \RjournalMagyar Tud. Akad. Mat. Fiz. Oszt. Közl. \Rvolume21 \Ryear1972
- [15]
August 04, 2020March 16, 2021Attila Berczes