Calabi-Yau metrics of Calabi type with polynomial rate of convergence
Abstract.
We present new complete Calabi-Yau metrics defined on the complement of a smooth anticanonical divisor with ample normal bundle, approaching the Calabi model space at a polynomial rate. Moreover, we establish the uniqueness of this type of Calabi-Yau metric within a fixed cohomology class.
1. Introduction
In 1978, Yau [22] gave the celebrated proof of Calabi conjecture by solving the Monge-Ampère equation for each Kähler class on compact Kähler manifolds. In 1990, Tian and Yau [20] expanded upon this achievement by constructing complete Calabi-Yau metrics on quasi-projective manifolds, extending the techniques introduced in [22] to the non-compact case. Specifically, when is a Fano manifold and is a smooth irreducible anticanonical divisor, they constructed complete Calabi-Yau metric on , called Tian-Yau metric. is exponentially close to the Calabi model space. Here the Calabi model space is the disc bundle over within removing the zero section, with complex structure given by , Kähler metric given by Calabi anstaz and a nowhere vanishing -form . The strict definition of Calabi model space will be given in Section 2. In fact, for any compact supported class in , we can find Calabi-Yau metric exponentially close to the Calabi model space. We call the complete Calabi-Yau manifold with this property asymptotically Calabi, which is defined as follows.
Definition 1.1.
Let be an -dim complete Kähler manifold with, complex structure , 2-form and -form . We say is
-
(1)
weak asymptotically Calabi with rate if there exists , , a Calabi model space with function on defined in Section 2, and a diffeomorphism , where and are compact, such that the following hold uniformly as :
-
(2)
asymptotically Calabi if it is weak asymptotically Calabi and
The asymptotically Calabi Calabi-Yau manifold is well understood by Hein-Sun-Viaclovsky-Zhang [7], in which they showed that any asymptotically Calabi Calabi-Yau manifold can be compactified complex analytically to a weak Fano manifold, i.e. a smooth projective manifold with nef and big anti-canonical bundle. In this paper, we are going to show the existence and uniqueness of weak asymptotically Calabi Calabi-Yau metrics that is not asymptotically Calabi. Our setting is as follows:
Definition 1.2.
Let be a compact Kähler manifold with complex dimension , be a smooth divisor with ample normal bundle and . We denote as the subset of which consists of classes such that is positively paired with any compact analytic subset of of pure complex dimension .
The main result of this paper is the following
Theorem 1.3.
For any class in , there exists a Calabi-Yau metric in the class which is weak asymptotically Calabi with rate .
To show the existence, we use the method in Tian-Yau [20], which was subsequently generalized and refined by Hein [8]. This Tian-Yau-Hein’s package facilitates the production of complete Calabi-Yau metrics when a suitable model metric at infinity is known. However, we cannot directly apply it here because the 2-form on coming from the restriction of 2-forms on will only decay at the rate , while Tian-Yau-Hein’s package requires the Ricci potential decays faster than . We need to modify our background metric by solving the linearized operator of Monge-Ampère equation to improve the decay.
Remark 1.4.
The metric in Theorem 1.3 is new in the sense that under a fixed diffeomorphism , is weak asymptotically Calabi with rate but not asymptotically Calabi. We can also find Calabi-Yau metrics when . However, these metrics are not new. In fact, the 2 dimensional case is well understood: Sun-Zhang [17] showed that the gravitational instanton is always asymptotically Calabi.
Besides, we also prove that the constructed metric is unique in the sense that:
Theorem 1.5.
Fix any . Let be the distance function towards under the metric in Theorem 1.3. If we have another Calabi-Yau metric in the same class satisfying
for some positive constant , then .
One could always have uniqueness if the metrics in Theorem 1.5 are close with rate for some large enough. Nevertheless, this rate is much faster than the decay rate of our metric constructed in Theorem 1.3. The proof of uniqueness theorem under any polynomial closeness requires two ingredients: the lemma with the estimate on , and the Liouville type theorem on .
Outline of the paper
The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, we provide an introductory overview of the Calabi ansatz, denoted by , within an open neighborhood of the divisor in its normal bundle, excluding the zero section. Our exposition primarily adheres to the notation and discussion presented by Hein, Sun, Viaclovsky, and Zhang [10]. Furthermore, we briefly review the analytical framework developed by Tian, Yau, and Hein [8], list some geometric properties of the Calabi model space that facilitates the application of uniform elliptic estimates later.
In section 3, we have the solution of the Poisson equation with appropriate weighted estimates. The method of variable separation, as detailed by Sun and Zhang [16], allows us to simplify the Poisson equation in the model space into a particular form of ordinary differential equation. Leveraging the solutions’ estimates for these ordinary differential equations, as presented in Appendix A, we construct an inversion of the Laplacian operator within suitably weighted spaces. This enables us to initiate the iterative processes detailed in Sections 4 and 5.
In Sections 4 and 5, we construct a good background metric within the cohomology class . We solve the Poisson equation on the model space iteratively to enhance the decay rate of the Ricci potential of , as detailed in Section 4. In Section 5, we refine the Kähler potential by incorporating the harmonic moment map alongside other pluri-subharmonic functions. This adjustment ensures not only the positivity of but also its compliance with the integral condition outlined in Tian-Yau-Hein’s package [8]. The iterative method adopted here is inspired by Conlon and Hein [5]. The specific technique of modifying the potential via the harmonic moment map is equivalent to choosing appropriate scaling of the metric on the normal bundle in Hein, Sun, Viaclovsky, and Zhang [7].
In Section 6, we deform our good background metric to a genuine Calabi-Yau metric on by Tian-Yau-Hein’s package. We also show that the perturbed metric is weak asymptotically Calabi with rate . This requires a slight generalization of Hein’s decay result in [8].
In Section 7, we discuss the uniqueness with restricted asymptotics of the Calabi-Yau metric in the fixed class. We first prove the -lemma on based on the global Hörmander estimate. Then by our solution of the Poisson equation and the behavior of the harmonic function on the model space we can deduce the global estimate to do integration by parts.
In Section 8, we present some examples of Calabi-Yau manifolds which are weak asymptotically Calabi but not asymptotically Calabi under a fixed diffeomorphism. We also make some conjectures about the stronger uniqueness theorem and the compactification and classification of weak asymptotically Calabi manifold or under even weaker condition.
In the following sections, and will be two uniform constants that may vary.
Other works on complete non-compact Calabi-Yau manifolds
There are many progress in the exploration of new complete Calabi-Yau manifolds, extending the seminal work of Tian and Yau to cases where is singular. Collins-Li [2] constructed new complete Calabi-Yau metrics when consists of two proportional transversely intersecting smooth divisors. The metric in their construction is exact and polynomially closed to the generalized Calabi anstaz. Later Collins-Tong-Yau [3] solved a certain free boundary Monge-Ampère equation crucial to the inductive strategy proposed in [2] to deal with the general case when is simple normal crossing.
There are also many interesting works on this problem based on Tian-Yau-Hein’s package. For example, the non-flat Calabi-Yau metric on constructed by Li [12], Székelyhidi [18] and Conlon-Rochon [6] with maximal volume growth, and Min [13] with volume growth when is even. Those works constructed Calabi-Yau with singular tangent cone at infinity.
Recently, Apostolov-Cifarelli [1] constructed new complete Calabi-Yau metrics on with volume growth . Their new method using toric geometry and Hamiltonian 2-forms is significantly different from Tian-Yau-Hein package and produces exotic complete Calabi-Yau metrics with interesting behavior at infinity.
Acknowledgement
The author is deeply grateful to Professor Song Sun for suggesting this problem, enlightening discussion and constant support. The author thanks Junsheng Zhang for fruitful conversation and encouragement, and thanks Yueqing Feng and Hongyi Liu for reading the draft of the paper and many helpful comments.The author also thanks IASM for their hospitality during the visit when the research was partially carried out, and the NSF for the generosity of the grant DMS-2304692.
2. Calabi model space
Let us give a brief introduction of Calabi ansatz and some notations we will use later. The notations in this section mainly follow Hein-Sun-Viaclovsky-Zhang [10, Section 3].
2.1. Calabi ansatz
Let be an -dimensional compact Kähler manifold with , be a smooth anticanonical divisor with ample normal bundle and let denote the complement of in . By adjunction formula we know that has trivial canonical bundle with a nowhere-vanishing holomorphic volume form such that
Hence by Yau’s theorem, up to scaling we have a unique hermitian metric on with curvature form on in the class satisfying
We fix such an . For any point , let and be functions on the complement of the zero section in the total space . Let be the disc bundle over with complex structure restricted from . On , we have a Calabi-Yau metric given by the Calabi ansatz:
Let denotes the unique holomorphic -form on such that
where denotes the holomorphic vector field generated by the scalar multiplication along the fiber direction and is the projection map. And the data is called Calabi model space.
On we can also choose a holomorphic section of to be the defining function of such that can be seen as an -form on with a simple pole and residue along . We choose a metric of such that . Then we can construct the following -form on :
As proved in Hein-Sun-Viaclovsky-Zhang [10, Proposition 3.4.], it is asymptotically Calabi in the following way:
Proposition 2.1.
The complex structure and , metric and and canonical form and are exponentially closed. To be more precise: there exists a compact set in , a compact set in , and a diffeomorphism induced by exponential map such that for all :
2.2. Geometric properties and Tian-Yau-Hein’s package
Let us first list some geometry of Calabi model space directly coming from the formula of . is complete when and incomplete when . It has volume growth of order and its sectional curvature decays at the rate . Any distance function on will be comparable to .
Then we introduce some requirements of the base Riemannian manifold in Tian-Yau-Hein’s package and show that our model space satisfies those properties. One may refer to [8] for details and examples.
We begin with the definition of property:
Definition 2.2.
Let be a complete noncompact Riemannian manifold with real dimension at least 3. We say satisfy condition for some if and only if there exists a point and a positive constant such that
-
(1)
Volume growth is at most , i.e. for all .
-
(2)
, .
-
(3)
.
-
(4)
For any , any two points with can be joined by a curve of length at most , lying in the annulus .
Remark 2.3.
Proposition 2.4.
has property.
Proof.
follows from the Ricci-flat property of . For , recall that and the volume form . The distance function to some fixed point in is comparable to . Consequently, one can see that is comparable to the annulus in the sense that: for any and , we have
Similarly, for any , we have:
Also, we can see from the ansatz that the diameter of is comparable to , which shows that
With all these equivalence, we know that
Similarly for we have
To show , for large enough and any two points and with , we have . Then by the formula of we can join and by a curve of length at most lying in and consequently in the annulus .
Hence we have the condition on . ∎
We continue with the definition of property:
Definition 2.5.
We say that is , for some , , , if there exist and such that
-
(1)
for every with there exists a local holomorphic diffeomorphism from the unit ball into such that and ,
-
(2)
satisfies , and .
Tian-Yau [20, Proposition 1.2.] provides a simple criterion for a complete Kähler manifold to be . We refer to Hein’s thesis [8, Lemma 4.7.] for a slightly generalized statement and sketch of the proof.
Lemma 2.6.
A complete Kähler manifold with for some and is for every .
Proposition 2.7.
has property, for any and .
Proof.
The proof goes almost verbatim with the proof of Lemma 2.6. The proof of Lemma 2.6 only used the completeness to guarantee that the injectivity radius of local universal cover around has uniform lower bound independent of . Since is the disc bundle over , after we do rescaling by , the action gives the only collapsing direction which disappears after passing to the local universal cover. So the local universal cover has uniform curvature bound and is volume non-collapsing, which leads to uniform injectivity radius lower bound. ∎
Now we are ready to present the following result taken from Hein’s thesis [8] which is a powerful tool to give the existence of Calabi-Yau metric on complete noncompact Kähler manifold.
Theorem 2.8 (Tian-Yau-Hein’s Package).
Let be a complete noncompact Kähler manifold, which satisfies the condition and for some , . Let be the distance function to a fixed point with respect to the metric . Let satisfy on for some and . Then there exist and such that . Moreover . If in addition for some , then all such solutions belong to .
Remark 2.9.
2.3. Uniform elliptic estimates
The previous properties are mainly used to guarantee that we have weighted Sobolev inequality, weighted Hölder space, and can do weighted elliptic estimates.
Recall that the norm of a function on a ball inside a manifold is
If we scale the metric by a constant , i.e. , we then have
Now we can prove the uniform Schauder estimate here for future reference:
Proposition 2.10.
Let be a manifold satisfying property. Let and be smooth functions on such that . Then there exist some constants such that
Proof.
Fix any in . Let be the rescaled pull back metric on the unit ball in , let , . Since we use the pull back metric, the Laplacian is preserved. We have . Write this elliptic equation under the Euclidean coordinate, with for any integer , we have satisfies the following elliptic equation
(2.1) |
By the standard elliptic estimates on the Euclidean space and passing to the original metric we get the required estimate. To be more precise, by estimates we know that there exists a uniform constant only depends on such that for any
Consequently by Sobolev embedding, we know
Taking derivative of (2.1) under the Euclidean coordinate, we have:
And by bootstrapping and Sobolev embedding
Passing to the original metric, we know that for any
∎
3. Solving Poisson Equation on the Model Space
In this section, following the approach of Sun-Zhang in [16], we will use separation of variables to solve for , functions on and give some uniform estimate of our solution. We use the same notation introduced in section 2.
We first notice that is diffeomorphic to where the level set for a fixed and is equipped with an bundle structure over and a metric induced by . Let be the spectrum of the Laplacian on with respect to the metric . Let be the corresponding eigenfunctions with . They showed that for some and . Moreover, form an orthonormal basis of and each is homogeneous of degree under the action. The product structure allows us to do Fourier expansion on . In particular, for any smooth function on , if we take , we can write
(3.1) |
which is convergent in sense. In fact, we will prove later that the convergence is in if has proper higher regularity estimate. For the separated function we have
Moreover, [16] proved the following:
Proposition 3.1.
Let be the Calabi model space, and let solve the Poisson equation for some and sufficiently large. Let , have ”fiber-wise” expansions as in (3.1). Then for every , the coefficient functions and satisfy
(3.2) |
Specifically, they found a solution of by solving ODE (3.2). With the estimate of the solution of this equation, they showed that the formal solution given by is actually a regular solution to the Poisson equation. Similarly but directly via careful estimates, we can construct the solution of Poisson equation with respect to with some weighted regularity and finer polynomial growth order:
Proposition 3.2.
Assume that is a function on such that for any there exist constants and such that on . Then there exist constants and a function such that and
on , for any and any integer .
Proof.
Let
be the formal solution, where is constructed as follows and is constructed in the Appendix A which mainly follows from Sun-Zhang [16].
Step 1: We first show that the formal solution converges in sense with the polynomial order depending on the polynomial order of .
For , we have
We choose and here to be or depending on the order of to make and finite with proper order. Also, the integration here is the only place that we will lose the rate .
For , we first prove that the projection is well-defined and has the following estimate:
(3.3) |
for any and . Consequently, the solution constructed in (A.3) and (A.9) for the equation (3.2) has the following bound for :
(3.4) |
Here the constant is uniform for and and only depends on and .We also have the uniform estimate of as the eigenfunctions of on by its eigenvalues showed in Sun-Zhang [16, Lemma 5.1.]:
(3.5) |
Combine (3.4) and (3.5), we get
Weyl’s law gives the bound of with for some only depend on . Take we can conclude that the summation converges.
Step 2: We prove that is smooth. We mostly follow the proof in Sun-Zhang [16, Proposition 6.2.]. Let
Then we have .
We first show that has bound independent of . In fact, we have the higher regularity estimate for as in (3.3):
Then given by the estimate of (3.5), for any integer , we know that
So again by Weyl’s law converges to as a function. Now we can prove that also have the uniform bound with respect to via local elliptic estimates.
For any fixed point , we consider the ball . Then for any , there exists a constant such that
By bootstrapping and Sobolev embedding, for any and , there exists a constant such that
Consequently we have converges to in . Since is arbitrary, we know that is smooth on .
Step 3. We can now give global bound on the , and higher regularity of . We treat and seperately.
For , we have explicit estimate by computation of the Christoffel symbol under the following holomorphic coordinate: Let be the projection map. For any point we take the local holomorphic coordinate on around the point . Take be a local holomorphic section of such that , where with , . Then where is the fiber coordinate. Recall that , and
Under this coordinate, we can prove by induction that
(3.6) |
Now we can estimate the higher derivative of :
where refers to the higher derivative of the function . Since
we know that
By and for , we have
Consequently, we have
and for
For we use our bound of and do elliptic estimate around a point by Proposition 2.10. We have the uniform estimate of on :
which yields
Together with the estimate of , we have
∎
Remark 3.3.
We see from the proof that the main term in and estimate of the solution is the fiber direction . However, for the higher estimate where , they will give the same order contribution.
4. Improve the Decay of the Ricci potential
Now we look back at the quasi-projective manifold and the class . In this section we are going to find a good representative form inside the class . We look at its behavior on the model space and then find some function by finite step iteration such that
has faster decay rate.
4.1. A good representative
Lemma 4.1.
For any , there exists a closed -form on such that .
Proof.
By discussion in Section 2 of [7] we know is weak Fano, and consequently simply connected by [19]. Consider the exact sequence , we have long exact sequence
On the other hand, by Serre duality we have
Apply Kawamata–Viehweg vanishing theorem to the nef and big line bundle so we know that for . So when , we have . The long exact sequence given by the excision theorem and Thom-Gysin sequence
yields that the restriction map induced by is surjective with , generated by . Hence there exists a closed -form on such that . ∎
Remark 4.2.
Here we use the fact that to apply Kawamata–Viehweg vanishing theorem. When we have , so may not vanish.
The global form on satisfies the following property on the end:
Proposition 4.3.
Let be the fixed diffeomorphism and let be the projection map. Then .
Proof.
Let be a fixed point in . Let be local holomorphic coordinates around this point such that is given by . Then can also be seen as a group of local holomorphic coordinates around in where represent the fiber direction. We can express locally around on as
Notice that we have the estimate of , , , and the complex structure is exponentially decay as in Proposition 2.1, we know that on we have
On the other hand, we know that . So extends to a smooth form on vanishing on the zero section , which yields . ∎
4.2. Iteration process
With this exponential closeness, we can view as a -form on with only horizontal direction component. This will greatly simplify our computation below.
Definition 4.4.
Let be a -form on . We define , called -potential.
Definition 4.5.
Proposition 4.6.
With ’s and ’s defined in 4.5, we have decays faster than . More precisely, for any positive integer and
(4.1) |
Proof.
We prove (4.1) by induction.
For , we can see this estimate directly follows from computation:
By (3.6) we know that , for any positive integer . So when (4.1) holds.
Assume (4.1) holds for , i.e. , for any . By straightforward computation,
Actually, the function in each term is of the from
(4.2) |
where is a set with repeated elements from , is a non-negative integer and positive when . By Proposition 3.2 we know that . It is easier to deduce the bound for (4.2) by passing to the rescaled metric on , where , . We have the uniform weighted bound for each term in the wedge product
5. The Integral Condition
For the convenience of statement, let us introduce the following notation.
Definition 5.1.
For an form , we say that a (1,1)-form is -compatible if .
Remark 5.2.
Since and are not integrable for most of the time, this integration identity means that the function satisfies .
In this section, we will show that by adding a suitable potential we can make to be -compatible.
Proposition 5.3.
There exists a smooth function on such that is an -compatible Kähler form. Meanwhile, we have that
when for some constant and .
Proof.
We first show that we can find such that is integrable on the end. Recall that we have and are functions on such that
We know that the following integration is finite since :
Since we have the exponentially closed estimate between and , we will have
Now we can construct the Kähler potential following the construction in Hein-Sun-Viaclovsky-Zhang [7, Lemma 2.7.]:
The ampleness of implies that is 1-convex. Hence by Remmert reduction we know that is semi-ample, we denote its non-ample locus by . Recall that for any -dimensional compact subvariety in , by the generalized Demailly-Păun criterion in [4] we know that there exists a smooth function on such that is positive on the neighborhood of . Let be a smooth function on support on and on . Then is positive around and is supported on .
Let , then the curvature form and on . Let be a smooth cutoff function on such that on and on . Then is positive on and supported on .
Let be a smooth convex function on with on and on . Then we can obtain that on and on .
Let
By our choice of , is positive around . By choosing and large we can make is positive on . Then choosing large enough depending on and we have that is positive on hence Kähler on .
Then we can glue our perturbation function via a cut-off function supported outside a compact set with outside a open neighborhood of and let
Our goal next is to find suitable and such that is Kähler and -compatible.
Let us first show that the -compatible condition is a linear equation of and only the constant term depends on the choice of . By our previous estimate of we know as a starting point that is finite. The -compatible condition becomes
Expanding the terms in the bracket, we notice that only remains non-vanishing after we take the limit, so we have the equation
This is a linear equation on . On the other hand, we also notice by the previous computation that does not affect the integral, so we can choose first to satisfy the integral condition and then choose large enough such that is Kähler. So by choosing
we finish our proof. ∎
In order to apply Tian-Yau-Hein’s package, we need to repeat the iteration process for one more step such that the -potential of decays faster than .
Proposition 5.4.
Furthermore, we can construct a Kähler -compatible form on such that
where is the distance function to some point under metric , .
Proof.
Let , . Let be the solution of constructed in Proposition 3.2.
By Proposition 3.2, we know that , which is of the same order of . Then
We know from the estimate in Proposition 3.2 that . So .
Let , we can choose large enough such that is Kähler on . Also we see from the construction of that
(5.1) |
Fix a point . Let denote the distance function to with the metric . With this asymptotic behavior, we know that is in the same order of the distance function on . Then outside a compact set on we have the estimate that
For the -compatible condition, we notice that the small term does not affect the integration of the form :
So is a Kähler form satisfying both -compatible condition and decay condition in Tian-Yau-Hein’s package. ∎
6. Existence and the proof
Now we are ready to apply Tian-Yau-Hein’s package to deform our metric to a Calabi-Yau metric.
Theorem 6.1.
For any class in , there exists a Calabi-Yau metric in the class .
Proof.
Let be the good representative we chose in be the potential constructed in section 5 with the form . We know that is a Kähler metric on such that
decays in order and , here is any distance function under the metric . Let
We have satisfies integral condition and the decay condition .
On the other hand, we have higher regularity estimate of ’s:
for any with some . Then we have higher estimate of metric and scalar curvature. So satisfies the condition by Lemma 2.4 and by Lemma 2.6 for any and .
So we know that there exists a function on such that
(6.1) |
with . ∎
The iteration process shows that for any , there exists function and constant such that
If we choose such that the potential decays fast enough, we can show that the solution of (6.1) also decays fast to a constant. To do this, we first present the following local Poincaré lemma for manifold with :
Lemma 6.2.
Assume is a complete Kähler manifold satisfying condition with , and as for some fixed , . Let such that for all , and . Then for any , there exists such that if and , then
for any .
Remark 6.3.
The proof is entirely same as the proof in [8, Proposition 4.8(ib)]. The only difference is that we choose to be . So we omit the proof here.
Then we can improve the bound of our solution to get the optimal close rate of our weak asymptotically Calabi metric:
Theorem 6.4.
For any class in , there is a Calabi-Yau metric in which is weak asymptotically Calabi with rate .
Proof.
With Lemma 6.2, together with [8, Proposition 4.8(ii)], we know that if we choose large enough, there exists a constant and such that the solution satisfies that
Then we can replace by to get a better candidate for the solution of (6.1), so could be chosen to decay at any polynomial rate. Repeat our local rescaling and local Schauder estimate, we know that the Calabi-Yau metric is polynomially closed to the Calabi model space with the leading error term .
If , the error term is exponentially close to Calabi model space. If is nonzero, the decay rate of is exactly . If we choose such that is primitive with respect to , the decay of would be , which is strictly lower order term compared with . Thus, the Calabi-Yau metric decays exactly at the rate , which is equivalent to . ∎
7. Uniqueness
In this section, we prove that the Calabi-Yau metric asymptotic to in the class is unique.
Theorem 7.1.
Let be the pair we considered before. If we have another Calabi-Yau metric in the same class satisfying , when , for some distance function with respect to and some , then .
Remark 7.2.
We are also interested in the problem that how different choice of the diffeomorphism will change our Calabi-Yau metric. For example, the scaling in the fiber direction will change the metric by the rate and by our uniqueness theorem, we get the same Calabi-Yau metric.
The proof of the theorem can be sketched as follows. We start with a -lemma by solving equation via the method. Then we can write with some estimate on . By pulling back to , we construct on the model space to solve the Poisson equation . Via the estimate of harmonic function on in Sun-Zhang [16], we can use the equation and take integration by parts to deduce that .
Lemma 7.3.
There exists a smooth function on such that with on for any and some .
Proof.
We prove the lemma by several steps:
Step 1: We show that there exists a smooth -form on such that with .
After pulling back to the model space we have is a closed 2-form with . By viewing as , we can write it as
with , . Then the fact that implies , . So we can choose
such that
Since , we have the decay of which implies that
Given the formula of we can have an estimate of at the point :
After extending as a smooth 1-form on , we can write for some smooth compact supported closed 2-form on X.
Recall that is 1-convex. Then by the vanishing theorem for 1-convex manifold from Van Coevering [21] Proposition 4.2., for some compact supported function on . Then is the smooth 1-form that we are looking for.
Step 2: Recall that is the non-ample locus of . The admits a complete Kähler metric by Proposition 4.1 in Ohsawa [15]. So we can use -estimate on to solve the equation to construct the potential such that .
Let . Choose , and large, then choose small depending on , we can guarantee that the form
is a Kähler form on . We have outside a compact set.
If we take the type decomposition of , we have the estimate of that for and supported on .
So with the same weighted estimate in Hein-Sun-Viaclovsky-Zhang [7, Proposition 2.2.], we have
which yields that we have a solution such that with
Consequently, we have . Set then we have .
Step 3: We give the bound and bound for via elliptic estimates on the scaled metric.
Let be any point in . With the same local elliptic estimate under the scaled metric as in Proposition 3.2, we can give a global bound of . We know that satisfies the elliptic equation with
since we have some uniform constant such that for any and any . By adjusting small enough we have
Now we can do local elliptic estimates on the scaled metric after lifting to the universal cover. Since the direction on collapsing in polynomial order with respect to , we know that
We have the global bound for :
for any . ∎
Remark 7.4.
In the proof of the -lemma 7.3 we did not use the polynomial decay of . In fact, we can always find even when is polynomially growth.
Furthermore, we can prove that has weighted higher regularity bound.
Lemma 7.5.
There exists a constant such that
for any .
Proof.
Fix any point in with . We still work on the scaled metric with uniform bounded curvature. The injectivity radius of the universal covering around is bounded below by a universal constant independent of . Now we are working on the ball in the universal cover. Since is -exact, locally we can take integration of along the geodesic lines to have 1-form on such that
Consider the type decomposition of . The operator
constructed in [11, Theorem 8.9] satisfies that
and commutes with and . Then
Then we know by Sobolev lemma and iteration process that for any
Take , there exists such that
Let . We have
Let . We have . Hence with
By Schauder estimates we have higher regularity
which yields
for any . ∎
Then we are ready to prove the uniqueness:
Proof of Theorem 7.1.
Given by previous estimate, we have with . If we pull back to , by the closeness of complex structure we have
The function has higher regularity bound on :
By Proposition 3.2 there exists a smooth function on such that with
Since and for any , from the behavior of harmonic function [16, Proposition 5.3.] we know that for some and some harmonic -invariant function on with . Since holds uniformly for any , integration along the -fiber direction shows that and hence is at most polynomially growth. Again by [16, Proposition 5.3.] we know that .
Recall that satisfies that
by our previous construction we know that , so ,
(7.1) |
Thus by finite step iteration we can find a better candidate and another constant such that
On the other hand,
Consequently, , for any . From the equation of we know that
Hence by integration by parts and :
Since is a positive form, we know that . ∎
8. Discussion and Questions
8.1. Examples
We present examples that is a Calabi-Yau manifold not asymptotically Calabi but weak asymptotically Calabi under the fixed diffeomorphism . As discussed in the end of the proof of Theorem 1.3, we have the following:
Claim.
Example 8.1.
Let with two projection maps and . Then we have . is generated by and and the image of each of them under the map induced by the inclusion map is not parallel to . Choose a primitive representative of any of these two classes and apply Theorem 1.3 we will find a Calabi-Yau metric not asymptotically Calabi but weak asymptotically Calabi.
These kind of examples could be found on any Fano manifold with and . We can find many examples in Mori-Mukai [14]. Besides, there are also many examples in the weak Fano case but we do not have a simple topological sufficient condition.
8.2. Weaker Decay Condition
In our statement of uniqueness Theorem 1.5, we need the metric to be polynomially closed to . The main difficulty to get rid of this condition lies in how to deduce the decomposition of with for any , where we cannot do iteration to improve the decay of as in (7.1).
It is natural to ask the following question:
Question 8.2.
Can we prove a stronger uniqueness theorem: If we have another Calabi-Yau metric such that when for some distance function with respect to , then ?
One possible obstruction of this stronger uniqueness theorem is that we cannot rule out the possibility that there is a Calabi-Yau metric closed to the Calabi model space in a logarithm rate rather than any polynomial rate. The existence of this type of Calabi-Yau metric is also an interesting question to study.
8.3. Compactification and Classification
Hein-Sun-Viaclovsky-Zhang [7] showed that any asymptotically Calabi manifold which is Calabi-Yau can be compactified complex analytically to a weak Fano manifold and the Calabi-Yau comes from the construction by Tian-Yau-Hein’s package.
In the weak asymptotic Calabi manifold case, when we only have the exponential closeness of complex structure, even though the metric is polynomial close, we can still get that any weak asymptotically Calabi manifold which is Calabi-Yau can be compactified complex analytically to a weak Fano manifold by repeating the argument in [7] as one can also do estimate to construct the holomorphic function on from the holomorphic section of . The key difference is to show that the compactification we get is Kähler by considering the behavior of the class at the end. By our uniqueness Theorem 1.5 this Calabi-Yau metric comes from our generalized Tian-Yau construction in Theorem 1.3.
We would like to make the following conjecture to further generalize this into slower decay assumption.
Definition 8.3.
Let be a complete Kähler manifold with complex dimension , complex structure , Kähler form and -form . We say is polynomial asymptotically Calabi with rate if:
there exists , a Calabi model space , and a diffeomorphism , where and are compact, such that the following hold uniformly as :
for all .
Conjecture 8.4.
There are optimal constants and such that for any and , any polynomial asymptotically Calabi Calabi-Yau manifold with rate can be compactified complex analytically to a weak Fano manifold. Furthermore, the Calabi-Yau metric comes from our generalized Tian-Yau construction in Theorem 1.3.
When is large enough, we can still use estimate to construct holomorphic coordinate on the end of . However, the question to find optimal may not be approachable by method. From the uniqueness theorem 1.5 and the compactification process of weak asymptotically Calabi Calabi-Yau manifold, we expect that should be .
Appendix A estimate of the solution of ODE
In this section, we will look closely to the solution of the following ordinary differential equation:
where , and .
By the transformation in [16], we have two cases: zero node case when and non-zero node case when . We will give a brief summary of the estimate of fundamental solutions and have a estimate of with polynomial rate which slightly generalizes the results in [16].
A.1. fundamental solution of zero mode
In this section we focus on the zero mode: the equation
(A.1) |
By [16] we have the decay solution and growth solution of the homogeneous equation given by
(A.2) | |||
(A.3) |
where and have the following expression: for
Lemma A.1.
[16][Proposition 3.3.] We have the following uniform estimate:
-
(1)
For all , there is a constant such that
-
(2)
For all , we have
Corollary A.2.
[16] For , there exists a constant which only depends on such that
With those estimates, we can give a bound of . By computation in [16] we know that the Wronskian
Hence we have a solution of A.1 as follows:
(A.4) |
We firstly introduce an estimate of the solution of this ordinary differential equation:
Proposition A.3.
Recall that is the first nonzero positive eigenvalue of . Let be a function such that for . For any such that , we can find solution of equation such that , , on for some constant only depend on , and .
Proof.
Now we can estimate . Let . By integration by parts the first term in A.4 is bounded by a constant times the following term:
Here we also use the following observation: Since , we know that the maximum of on the interval is at when is larger than a uniform constant which is independent with respect to but only on and . So we have
For the second term , we have similar estimate:
So we have the uniform estimate for that for any ,
For the derivative we can do the same computation as in [16] to estimate and . In fact, we have the following estimate:
Lemma A.4.
for some fixed constant and any .
Proof.
Notice that
As in the proof of [16] Prop. 3.3, we know that for any
For and , let ,
So we get that .
On the other hand,
By the estimate of , we know that . ∎
Corollary A.5.
For , there exists a constant which only depends on such that
Proof.
Consequently, by integration by parts as before we have the estimate of :
and
for .
In the end, we get if on , then for any
∎
A.2. fundamental solution of non-zero mode
In this section we focus on the non-zero mode: the equation
(A.5) |
By [16] we have the decay solution and growth solution of the homogeneous equation given by
(A.6) | ||||
(A.7) |
where , , and have the following expression:
(A.8) | ||||
(A.9) |
Let , . Denote
Then is strictly concave in if . Let be the only critical point of . We have
Denote
Then is strictly concave in . Let be the only critical point of . Then
In [16] by Laplace method, we can show the following estimate:
Lemma A.6.
Corollary A.7.
We also need the following lemma
Lemma A.8.
For any , .
Proof.
By similar straight forward computation as in [16]. ∎
With those estimates, we can give a bound of . By [16] we know that the Wronskian
Hence we have a solution of (A.5) as follows:
(A.10) |
Then we can have the following estimate of our solution:
Proposition A.9.
Recall that is the first nonzero positive eigenvalue of . Let be a smooth function such that for . For any such that , we can find solution of equation such that , on for some constant only depends on , and .
Proof.
Similar as the zero-mode case, we estimate .
By integration by parts we have
where are given by
By straight forward computation and induction we can see that
So by taking large enough we have for some which will be chosen later.
We first consider the case that .
By Lemma A.8 the first term becomes
For the second term, we have similar estimate:
Then we consider the case where
So we have the uniform estimate for that for any ,
In the end, we get if on , then for any
∎
Remark A.10.
Even though the separation of variable method is very explicit, we can only get a bound of with respect to the polynomial growth order of rather than the function itself. This is mainly because the behavior of operator and is not clear for general function.
References
- [1] Vestislav Apostolov and Charles Cifarelli. Hamiltonian -forms and new explicit calabi–yau metrics and gradient steady kähler–ricci solitons on , 2023.
- [2] Tristan C. Collins and Yang Li. Complete calabi-yau metrics in the complement of two divisors, 2022.
- [3] Tristan C. Collins, Freid Tong, and Shing-Tung Yau. A free boundary monge-ampère equation and applications to complete calabi-yau metrics, 2024.
- [4] Tristan C. Collins and Valentino Tosatti. A singular demailly–păun theorem. Comptes Rendus Mathematique, 354(1):91–95, 2016.
- [5] Ronan J. Conlon and Hans-Joachim Hein. Asymptotically conical Calabi–Yau manifolds, I. Duke Mathematical Journal, 162(15):2855 – 2902, 2013.
- [6] Ronan J Conlon and Frédéric Rochon. New examples of complete calabi-yau metrics on for . arXiv preprint arXiv:1705.08788, 2017.
- [7] Jeff Viaclovsky Hans-Joachim Hein, Song Sun and Ruobing Zhang. Asymptotically calabi metrics and weak fano manifolds. 2023.
- [8] Hans-Joachim Hein. On gravitational instantons. 2010.
- [9] Hans-Joachim Hein. Gravitational instantons from rational elliptic surfaces. Journal of the American Mathematical Society, 25(2):355–393, 2012.
- [10] Hans-Joachim Hein, Song Sun, Jeff Viaclovsky, and Ruobing Zhang. Nilpotent structures and collapsing ricci-flat metrics on the k3 surface. Journal of the American Mathematical Society, 35:123–209, 2022.
- [11] J. J. Kohn. Harmonic integrals on strongly pseudo-convex manifolds, i. Annals of Mathematics, 78(1):112–148, 1963.
- [12] Yang Li. A new complete calabi–yau metric on . Inventiones mathematicae, 217(1):1–34, 2019.
- [13] Daheng Min. Construction of higher dimensional alf calabi-yau metrics, 2023.
- [14] Shigefumi Mori and Shigeru Mukai. Classification of fano 3-folds with . manuscripta mathematica, 36(2):147–162, 1981.
- [15] Takeo Ohsawa. Vanishing theorems on complete kähler manifolds. Publications of The Research Institute for Mathematical Sciences, 20:21–38, 1984.
- [16] Song Sun and Ruobing Zhang. A liouville theorem on asymptotically calabi spaces. Calculus of Variations and Partial Differential Equations, 60(3):103, 2021.
- [17] Song Sun and Ruobing Zhang. Collapsing geometry of hyperkähler 4-manifolds and applications, 2022.
- [18] Gábor Székelyhidi. Degenerations of and Calabi–Yau metrics. Duke Mathematical Journal, 168(14):2651 – 2700, 2019.
- [19] S Takayama. Simple connectedness of weak fano varieties. Journal of algebraic geometry, 9(2):403–407, 2000.
- [20] Gang Tian and Shing-Tung Yau. Complete kähler manifolds with zero ricci curvature. i. Journal of the American Mathematical Society, 3(3):579–609, 1990.
- [21] Craig van Coevering. A construction of complete ricci-flat kähler manifolds. arXiv: Differential Geometry, 2008.
- [22] Shing-Tung Yau. On the ricci curvature of a compact kähler manifold and the complex monge-ampére equation, i. Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, 31(3):339–411, 1978.